Character Review

Lord Sessadore · Nov 26, 2008

Yup, I got the email, just replied.

Thanks again for setting me up - it'll give me something D&D related to do while I'm bored

Lord Sessadore · Nov 26, 2008

Hmm, another question on procedure. If there is a character who has been reviewed by 2 people already, but they stated changes that need to be made and so withheld approval, do we usually have those same 2 people wait for the changes and approve?

garyh · Nov 26, 2008

Lord Sessadore said:
Hmm, another question on procedure. If there is a character who has been reviewed by 2 people already, but they stated changes that need to be made and so withheld approval, do we usually have those same 2 people wait for the changes and approve?

If the corrections are made and the comments addressed, I don't see why the original reviewer would have to be the final approver. So yeah, if the problems are fixed (and you don't find anymore), you can give an approval.

covaithe · Nov 26, 2008

Agreed.

Atanatotatos · Dec 2, 2008

Are there any characters waiting for approval? I have already reviewed 3-4 in the past and I can give it a couple of hours...

Dawn Raven · Dec 2, 2008

I could use an approval. Both Covaithe and Lord Sessadore have reviewed me and I made the changes they recommended. L4W

C:Les Ghentel (Dawn Raven - ENWiki)

Atanatotatos · Dec 2, 2008

Dawn Raven said:
I could use an approval. Both Covaithe and Lord Sessadore have reviewed me and I made the changes they recommended. L4WC:Les Ghentel (Dawn Raven - ENWiki)

Honestly I'm not sure on the procedure in your case, Dawn, since your character has already been approved by two reviewers... It's probably better if it is re-reviewed by one of them.

Dunamin · Dec 3, 2008

I'll try go get through a batch of submissions, then let you know what we have left Ata, thanks.

covaithe · Dec 3, 2008

Dawn Raven said:
I could use an approval. Both Covaithe and Lord Sessadore have reviewed me and I made the changes they recommended. L4WC:Les Ghentel (Dawn Raven - ENWiki)

It doesn't have to be me that checks things again after the changes I asked for, but it does need to be another full judge, since your other approval is from a trial judge.

I'd like to be able to promise that I'll get to this quickly, but I think I'd be lying if I did.

Dawn Raven · Dec 3, 2008

Hah! Time is of no essence. Les is not even in a game yet. Simply sitting around staring blank-faced at other adventurers and wondering what to do next.