Character Review

Lord Sessadore

Explorer

• Nov 26, 2008

• #51

Yup, I got the email, just replied.

Thanks again for setting me up - it'll give me something D&D related to do while I'm bored

 

log in or register to remove this ad

Lord Sessadore

Explorer

• Nov 26, 2008

• #52

Hmm, another question on procedure. If there is a character who has been reviewed by 2 people already, but they stated changes that need to be made and so withheld approval, do we usually have those same 2 people wait for the changes and approve?

 

garyh

First Post

• Nov 26, 2008

• #53

Lord Sessadore said:

Hmm, another question on procedure. If there is a character who has been reviewed by 2 people already, but they stated changes that need to be made and so withheld approval, do we usually have those same 2 people wait for the changes and approve?

Click to expand...

If the corrections are made and the comments addressed, I don't see why the original reviewer would have to be the final approver. So yeah, if the problems are fixed (and you don't find anymore), you can give an approval.

 

covaithe

Explorer

• Nov 26, 2008

• #54

Agreed.

 

Atanatotatos

First Post

• Dec 2, 2008

• #55

Are there any characters waiting for approval? I have already reviewed 3-4 in the past and I can give it a couple of hours...

 

Dawn Raven

First Post

• Dec 2, 2008

• #56

I could use an approval. Both Covaithe and Lord Sessadore have reviewed me and I made the changes they recommended. L4WC:Les Ghentel (Dawn Raven - ENWiki)

 

Atanatotatos

First Post

• Dec 2, 2008

• #57

Dawn Raven said:

I could use an approval. Both Covaithe and Lord Sessadore have reviewed me and I made the changes they recommended. L4WC:Les Ghentel (Dawn Raven - ENWiki)

Click to expand...

Honestly I'm not sure on the procedure in your case, Dawn, since your character has already been approved by two reviewers... It's probably better if it is re-reviewed by one of them.

 

Dunamin

First Post

• Dec 3, 2008

• #58

I'll try go get through a batch of submissions, then let you know what we have left Ata, thanks.

 

covaithe

Explorer

• Dec 3, 2008

• #59

Dawn Raven said:

I could use an approval. Both Covaithe and Lord Sessadore have reviewed me and I made the changes they recommended. L4WC:Les Ghentel (Dawn Raven - ENWiki)

Click to expand...

It doesn't have to be me that checks things again after the changes I asked for, but it does need to be another full judge, since your other approval is from a trial judge.

I'd like to be able to promise that I'll get to this quickly, but I think I'd be lying if I did.

 

Dawn Raven

First Post

• Dec 3, 2008

• #60

Hah! Time is of no essence. Les is not even in a game yet. Simply sitting around staring blank-faced at other adventurers and wondering what to do next.