Dungeon vs. Polyhedron - Death Match

Sholari · Jul 15, 2003

Just curious where the "masses" stand on this.

Numion · Jul 15, 2003

Bump.

I'm for Dungeon all the way.

Enceladus · Jul 15, 2003

A suggestion. change Poly to a tri annual publication. Or something. *shrug*

senodam · Jul 15, 2003

I couldn't honestly choose if I had to. IMO neither of the mags is sufficient to stand alone- that's the reason I had stopped buying Dungeon, and let my Poly go back in the day. But together..it just feels right to me. Looks like I'm a minority though.

Enceladus · Jul 15, 2003

bumpage

Thaumaturge · Jul 15, 2003

I like both magazines, and use info from them both regularly.

Thaumaturge.

The_Gneech · Jul 15, 2003

Insufficient choices. I like both.

-The Gneech

Iron_Chef · Jul 15, 2003

So far, the poll proves my opinion that far fewer people like Polyhedron over Dungeon when it comes right down to it. You notice all the pro-Poly posts, yet the votes don't support that position at all. Poly-lovers are a tiny minority incapable of financialy supporting a full-blown Poly. Those who want all Dungeon in their Dungeon far outnumber them (75%).

As I've said before, make Poly the "free subscriber content" and put back the missing pages of D&D adventures Poly stole from us! Then, the Poly-lovers can have their precious Poly and those of us in the majority who despise it can have our magazine back!

Desdichado · Jul 15, 2003

Iron_Chef said:
So far, the poll proves my opinion that far fewer people like Polyhedron over Dungeon when it comes right down to it. You notice all the pro-Poly posts, yet the votes don't support that position at all. Poly-lovers are a tiny minority incapable of financialy supporting a full-blown Poly. Those who want all Dungeon in their Dungeon far outnumber them (75%).

As I've said before, make Poly the "free subscriber content" and put back the missing pages of D&D adventures Poly stole from us! Then, the Poly-lovers can have their precious Poly and those of us in the majority who despise it can have our magazine back!

Yeah, 'coz that sample size is just so overwhelming!

I wouldn't buy Dungeon at all if it weren't for Poly, and at the end of the day, it's pretty much just the Poly that I read.