Dungeon vs. Polyhedron - Death Match

Sholari

First Post

• Jul 15, 2003

• #1

Just curious where the "masses" stand on this.

 

log in or register to remove this ad

Numion

First Post

• Jul 15, 2003

• #2

Bump.

I'm for Dungeon all the way.

 

Enceladus

First Post

• Jul 15, 2003

• #3

A suggestion. change Poly to a tri annual publication. Or something. *shrug*

 

S

senodam

First Post

• Jul 15, 2003

• #4

I couldn't honestly choose if I had to. IMO neither of the mags is sufficient to stand alone- that's the reason I had stopped buying Dungeon, and let my Poly go back in the day. But together..it just feels right to me. Looks like I'm a minority though.

 

Enceladus

First Post

• Jul 15, 2003

• #5

bumpage

 

Thaumaturge

Wandering. Not lost. (He/they)

• Jul 15, 2003

• #6

I like both magazines, and use info from them both regularly.


Thaumaturge.

 

The_Gneech

Explorer

• Jul 15, 2003

• #7

Insufficient choices. I like both.

-The Gneech

 

Iron_Chef

First Post

• Jul 15, 2003

• #8

So far, the poll proves my opinion that far fewer people like Polyhedron over Dungeon when it comes right down to it. You notice all the pro-Poly posts, yet the votes don't support that position at all. Poly-lovers are a tiny minority incapable of financialy supporting a full-blown Poly. Those who want all Dungeon in their Dungeon far outnumber them (75%).

As I've said before, make Poly the "free subscriber content" and put back the missing pages of D&D adventures Poly stole from us! Then, the Poly-lovers can have their precious Poly and those of us in the majority who despise it can have our magazine back!

 

Last edited: Jul 15, 2003

Desdichado

Hero

• Jul 15, 2003

• #9

Iron_Chef said:

So far, the poll proves my opinion that far fewer people like Polyhedron over Dungeon when it comes right down to it. You notice all the pro-Poly posts, yet the votes don't support that position at all. Poly-lovers are a tiny minority incapable of financialy supporting a full-blown Poly. Those who want all Dungeon in their Dungeon far outnumber them (75%).

As I've said before, make Poly the "free subscriber content" and put back the missing pages of D&D adventures Poly stole from us! Then, the Poly-lovers can have their precious Poly and those of us in the majority who despise it can have our magazine back!

Click to expand...

Yeah, 'coz that sample size is just so overwhelming! I wouldn't buy Dungeon at all if it weren't for Poly, and at the end of the day, it's pretty much just the Poly that I read.

 

Sir Osis of Liver

Explorer

• Jul 15, 2003

• #10

i wouldn't buy dungeon if it weren't for Poly. I rarely use mods, but mini games and industry news makes it worth getting the magazine.