Recent content by aramis erak

  1. aramis erak

    David Wesely: The Man Who Accidentally Invented RPGs

    All roleplay is fantasy, not all settings are purely fantasy, but the moment you add PCs, it moves into being fantasy. Remember fantasy has two meanings within literary use: one is a technical term for anything that doesn't exist, the other for settings build around that conceit for the major...
  2. aramis erak

    Gamesurvey.org – academic research on hobby gaming community

    Without looking at the list again, I can't be more specific, but the list is EXTREMELY board and computer focused... for example, RPGs have almost no 4X games, but do have romances, and 2X and 3X games (which 2 of the 4 X's vary; D&D tends to be explore and exterminate.)
  3. aramis erak

    The Answer is not (always) on your Character Sheet

    Sometimes, the fiction demands failure. Sometimes, it allows for complicated success. Sometimes, it allows for non-blocking failures. Sometimes, it's just important to give the clue. Sometimes failure means, "Pick a different method to get the clue"... All of which are part of an investigation...
  4. aramis erak

    The Answer is not (always) on your Character Sheet

    In my experience, almost always leads that way. It was explicitly for that No; it appeals to me, and resolution speed definitely isn't on my priority list. Ease of resolution, however, is, and in D&D 5, that was the single most attracktive element to me, with bounded accuracy being second. But...
  5. aramis erak

    Non-evocative Names

    I've met over a dozen Hmong named Chubaka/Chewbacca ... always in large families. It's apparently not gender specific.
  6. aramis erak

    The Answer is not (always) on your Character Sheet

    To me, it means the GM doesn't want one abstracting. In my experience, it's been a cognate for "Shut down the mechanics thinking and roleplay, you «bleep»!" I've never seen it lead to good RP nor a good time. Not even the few times I've used it. I have seen it lead to player frustration...
  7. aramis erak

    Non-evocative Names

    tlingon-Hol, Sindarin, and Quenya. Sparingly, at that. There are a lot. One of the largest conlangs, and arguably the most successful, is Church Slavonic, which was created by averaging the Balto-Slavic languages. I have much exposure to it from Church.
  8. aramis erak

    Non-evocative Names

    There's a reason I have a 20 page names book (digest sized) for L5R... most of which are well documented as actual japanese names. I have a similar (but smaller) one each for Pendragon and for LotR.
  9. aramis erak

    Gamesurvey.org – academic research on hobby gaming community

    That worked. I'll note that the genre list is pretty weak.
  10. aramis erak

    Gamesurvey.org – academic research on hobby gaming community

    II'm not able to get the page to load.
  11. aramis erak

    Adventure Time TTRPG Drops "Yes And" System, Switches To 5E

    Not entirely; there's the "PDFs are software" element, too. That's where a large part of the Disney restrictions were blamed on. (PostScript is a turing complete programming language, which just happens to be optimized for drawing on paper... and PDF is a container for post-script and a variety...
  12. aramis erak

    Any Christian rpgs?

    Magical Land of Yeld draws a lot of elements from Narnia; it then applies a good dose of Final Fantasy to it.
  13. aramis erak

    Adventure Time TTRPG Drops "Yes And" System, Switches To 5E

    No, it's not super weird. Unusual, yes. See, Star Wars is also so restricted... and it's arguably the largest licensed property in the industry. Lots of pirate PDFs... including all editions. It's a lack of understanding of the changing marketplace. The transformation in the last 20 years has...
  14. aramis erak

    What Games do you think are Neotrad?

    The things I think typify neotrad are Fully build characters by choices, not fortune. Provisions for cheating death of a PC. GM centric play formalized mechanics intended to be used Things I see concomitant but not at all definitive (but are definitive for not being Trad): metacurrency fine...
  15. aramis erak

    Describe your last rpg session in 5 words

    Wed Dragonbane Party mostly dead. What's next?
Top