Recent content by Grammarsalad

One of my favorite setting in 3e was called Dragonstar. It had all of the core classes but modified in a way that just worked (with a few added classes like pilots).

Have you checked out castles & crusades? It's closer to 3e that feels like 1e, but it is pretty cool imo

Okay, so this is just awesome! Do you accept requests? Personally, I'd love to see something like this for other settings (e.g. dragonlance). I would really love a write up like this on the religions of Eberron. Yeah, I know they don't have avatars, but I'm interested in seeing what that setting...

I'm old school, but in my school, we played palladium fantasy rpg. Not only did we have wolf people and rat people, we just straight up played trolls and ogres

Beholder 33 Displacer Beast 21 Gelatinous Cube 22 Githyanki 6 Gnoll 1 Lich 26 Mimic 25 Mind Flayer/Illithid 23 Owlbear 19 Purple Worm 24 Rust Monster 20 Umber Hulk 19

I did not notice this! And yet still, I imputed. And I don't think I was the only one Edit: I looked again in his basic rules, and I didn't find it I found this in the section titled "using these rules" which seems to say something different: "Part 1 is about creating a character, providing...

Exactly! I would put it like this: rather than using terms like "general" and "specific" I would place these rules in a hierarchy; at the top are the "first order rules" that apply to all rules of a lower order, but not to themselves. Here you can say that all rules of the lower order are domain...

You have me confused with the rule, my friend! My logic is impeccable; the rule is incoherent. But it is interesting that it still "works", isn't it? And it is interesting that is 'seems' plausible when in fact it isn't.

Lol, a stern look cannot override the logic. It cannot be a general rule that specific rules override general rules.

The rule that specific rules override general rules seems to have the form of a general rule; that is that it should be applied generally, in all relevant situations. However, if it is a general rule that specific rules should override general rules, then what of this general rule itself? It...

My suggestion: don't let your participants in on your hypothesis. ;)