Recent content by Jacob Marley

  1. J

    Missed session catch-up XP

    In my campaign XP is awarded as follows: Player present, PC participates in challenge = Full XP Player absent, PC participates in challenge = Full XP Player present, PC does not participate in challenge = No XP Player absent, PC does not participate in challenge = No XP I've been doing...
  2. J

    Everybody Cheats?

    I started recreating all my random tables in Google Docs. I am almost to the point where all I have in front of me while DMing is my iPad, a notebook, a pencil, and a single set of dice.
  3. J

    Comfort withcross gender characters based on your gender

    I use a miniature. DM: "What's your race?" Me: "Look at the mini." "What's your gender?" "Look at the mini." "Hair color?" "Mini." "Weapon?" "Mini!" "Armor?" "MINI!" "Class, let's see... fighter." "Nope, bard." "But you're wearing full plate?!?" "I couldn't find a dwarf bard mini." :erm:
  4. J

    Rudy from Alpha Investments: Hasbro prepping to sell WotC (wild speculation)

    Actually, I'd bet the other way. That is, Hasbro is not selling WotC to Disney, Hasbro is shedding under performing assets in order to sell itself to Disney (or Comcast, or Sony). It's no secret that Hasbro's goal was to be the next Marvel. And they have tried to follow Marvel's lead. It stands...
  5. J

    Creating a Character VS Discovering a Character

    I like both methods. I've used both methods. I'm currently using 4d6DL with a character stable in my 3.5 campaign. IMHO, that method provides my players with enough statistical variance to fulfill a character concept, but also allows for some level of character discovery. Sure, but 3.5 has a...
  6. J

    How much back story do you allow/expect at the start of the game?

    Quite frankly, I'd rather a player be explicit about what hooks their character than tease that information out of a multi-page backstory. Give me three-to-five sentences that explicitly express a belief, a goal, a motivation, a rival, a plot-line, whatever, and fill in the details as they...
  7. J

    D&D 5E Point Buy vs Rolling for Stats

    Really? Yellow! Jacob "Who's eyes now hurt from trying to read Lanefan's post" Marley :p
  8. J

    D&D 5E Point Buy vs Rolling for Stats

    I'll take that bet! The rest of the stat block is only possible with an 18 Dex. He's a level 10 Thief with an AC of 2. You need a minimum Dex of 9 to be a Thief, and he only has +1 Leather and a Ring of Protection +1 to adjust his AC. In order to get an AC of 2 with what's written in his stat...
  9. J

    D&D 5E Is infinite diversity in infinite combinations .... a terrible thing in D&D?

    From what I've read of his posts, I don't see any reason why we should restrict Blue from playing D&D with us.
  10. J

    D&D 5E Point Buy vs Rolling for Stats

    Nah, we're just broadening the definition (see: Mary Sue, LWQF, sandbox, railroad, fudging, etc., etc., etc. ;)).
  11. J

    D&D 5E Point Buy vs Rolling for Stats

    Got it. Thank you for sharing the results of your analysis.
  12. J

    D&D 5E Point Buy vs Rolling for Stats

    What your analysis does is it provides us with a baseline for discussion. It establishes the inherent mathematical outcomes within this edition, assuming all other things being equal. What it doesn't do, however, is put a period on the discussion of survivability. In order to examine this idea...
  13. J

    D&D 5E Point Buy vs Rolling for Stats

    When running these analyses, are you looking strictly at the mathematical chances character A has versus character B straight up in an unremarkable environment? That is, hell hound and character stand toe-to-toe, each hitting the other until one of them falls? By contrast, in an environment...
  14. J

    D&D 5E Survivor Campaign Settings II: Blackmoor Wins!

    Blackmoor 16 Lankhmar 0 Goodbye! It's sad to see you go, but it's time to bring this thread to a close. Mystara 11
Top