Recent content by Superchunk77

The black and white image with the torch held high does no favors to differentiate it either.

There's some yeah. I guess it's more of a Shadowdark smushed together with Knave 2e then.

Shadowdark for one.

So he's making a Shadowdark clone that uses different dice sizes. Meh.

Every book has fans. The book achieved only average sales when it was first released. To me, that's not selling well. Well the first two did and they were awful. Book went back on the shelf after that. I read enough of it to know it wasn't good.

Reviews are only as good as the reviewer, and are very subjective. I (like most others I imagine) find reviewers that I know I can trust to give honest reviews, and who's tastes align with my own. But it did not sell well. No, Star Trek's Earth (and it's federation of planets) is a socialist...

Adventures are boring/silly/dumb and the setting itself makes no sense. It's essentially written like a socialist utopia where nothing really bad can ever happen. I mean, if you want a D&D setting where the PC's don't actually adventure, and instead just enter cooking competitions, then I...

I don't really see the difference. Both are based on the same setting, which is where the problems begin.

When adventure books are badly written, the writers tend to be the reason. Putting a bad writer onto another project doesn't usually result in a good outcome. Pretty self-explanatory.

Another Radiant Citadel writer. Expectations lowered.

Fellow Canadian here, and yes, I agree we should be able to produce our own books, along with many other manufactured goods within Canada. But unfortunately our current government party in power relies on heavy carbon taxes and anti-small business regulations that make such endeavors infeasible...

Sweet Jesus no.

Thank you for saying that.

DC20 is definitely not 5e.

It's also notable that there were zero 5e powered games that got nominated (I think?).