Recent content by The Shaman

I really think I've answered this question already. In my reply, I specifically referred to the example as "hypothetical," as in, at any table at which I've personally played. I've been reflecting on my experience here at EN World for the past couple of months, and I came to a conclusion the...

If I've explained the situation, set the minis out, drawn a map and a sketch, answered any and all questions, and the player still doesn't get it? Then it doesn't matter, 'cause I quit. Seriously, there's nothing about this hypothetical that strikes me in the least bit plausible.

Just out of curiosity, where are the other players in this scenario? Why aren't they looking out for each other?

No, the key words are "should ask." Again, I'll go over the specifics of something as much or as little as the players want. I have maps and diagrams and pictures and miniatures to illustrate the scene, and I'll whip up a sketch if something still isn't clear. It's a description of a room, not...

Elf Witch, it's not often you and I agree, but in this we are in complete accord. Especially that last line.

Y'know, you could just have it drop near them if they're contemplating something stupid, as a warning from the gods. Player 1: "Forget sneaking in! Let's just rush the gate!" Referee: "FWOOOOOSH! BOOM!" Player 1: "Another haycart?" Player 2: "Seriously, you are just not cut out to play the...

Exactly. If the players aren't sure about something, they should ask. I'm happy to give them all the description they want, put minis on the table, draw a sketch, show them a picture - whatever helps to frame it in their minds. But they need to take the initiative to ask, and they are...

Don't expect. React.

Telling the player that, if his character flees, he may as well roll a new character, is not how I would handle it myself. Let the player make his choice, let the other players make theirs, then assess the outcome. Other than that, I agree that giving the player hints is not a style of play...

If your players aren't having fun, you may be playing with the wrong players.

EN World is representative of jack and :):):):).

"Often incorrect?" Man, I'm so tired of "blame the referee" :):):):):):):):).

This is why you have children, 'cause no one bats an eye if you're playing action figures with your kids. ;)

Only when I read some of the :):):):) that gets posted on message boards.

That was how I ran 3e as well - I just eyeballed everything.