Search results

Well, you are correct we are not privy to what WOTC is doing behind the scenes :D. So, it is possible that they have tried this but until they say so I am going to hold them to the idea that they promoted 5E and that was game that would have a core chassis as appealing to as many people as...

I did not imply anything. I was just giving an example of part of a boom—not that it created the boom. I didn't imply it at all you took it that way because you are looking for something to attack. It is like someone saying rap really became popular and becoming more mainstream in the early...

Okay. Let's put this in perspective: 1. Someone ask me a question about 1E 2. I respond to that person 3. You jump in doing personal attacks claiming I was not around in the 80's, do not know OSR and bunch of other nonsense 4. I state (factually) I was around in the 80's and did play OSR...

Never said the D&D cartoon created the boom but believe what you will.

What people are calling an "explosion" is still on obscure niche. D&D and RPGs have never been a popular hobby for the masses. That may change but anyone who says it is now or has been is living in a false reality. Options in a niche in which one main provider occupies most of the niche is...

First of all, I didn't lecture of gamesplain to anyone. I was asked a question. I responded to the question. Then you jumped in. If you did not like the answer then why don't you do as your moniker says and stay low-key. Secondly, I was around in the 80's. 3. D&D went through a brief boom...

1E and 2E both are considered OSR. I did not start in 1E never said that. I do have 1e books though and have been retro games of 1E. So I have familiarity (and respect) for 1E. I also did have other RPGs at the time but feel free to address made up conclusions. I mean, you like narrative play...

Actually I started playing 1989 which was 2E. That being said. I am aware other RPGs were out BUT they were not "popular" some people knew about them but when The AD&D PHB was released in 1978 there was not an RPG "market". IN FACT, for a long time even into the 90's to say RPGs were a market...

Yeah dude I don't know what the face palm is but D&D was the original RPG. It did not have a lot of mechanical differences so you had to make stuff up to differentiate your character class from another player playing the exact same class. The differences were minimal buit you didn't know any...

A lot of playtesting went into 5E that being said I do think maybe Jeremy Crawford does not get as much credit as he deserves. From Sage Advice and everything else I wonder he is more of the tactical mind behind 5E whereas Mike is the overall big picture guy/narrative guy...

Well, in 2E due to the various conditions at TSR when the person who did not really like D&D took over there was actually very little playtesting in general. You also correct that the Players Option series was not play-tested in fact the Combat & Tactics and Skills & Powers books were evidently...

For the same reason people want WOTC to publish official campaign worlds instead of one of the numerous third party worlds out there. People enjoy official products. I am partly joking and partly serious. Official products in theory have had better playtesting. Official products are often...

I started D&D in 2E and played every edition since. 4 is my favorite but I like 5E two and I currently am playing in my second 5E campaign. I have DMed but mostly I have been a player. While I like 5E I (along with most of my group) are rather disappointed at the pace of rules production...

I will just copy what I posted in the WOTC forums on this matter: My concerns on this article are is that 1) by using "creative improvisation" it allows to much abuse from both a player and a DM perspective. Spells should have a set mechanic so that a player knows exactly what happens from a...

You might have a point on this one. Moving the powers of each class to their own section and just having the classes separately wouldn't bother me too much. The 3rd edition version of Warhammer Fantasy Role-play incorporates playing cards with 4E style power like abilities for all careers and...

THACO may not have been that bad but it wasn't that great either especially when combined with all the other clunky parts of 2E i.,e the lower the armor class the better, the lower the initiative the better (but don't forget to include casting time and Weapon Speed Factor to the roll), multiple...

You keep talking about adding wizards and elves to the game like that was what added the fluff. It was a fantasy wargame, those are part of the genre. I will agree that perhaps Gygax designed the rules around the "fluff" in the sense that he designed the rules to mimic much of what he had read...

No, it has not always been the fluff that made DnD. Yes, the rules have changed between each edition of DnD but there have been those people who have always looked at the rules in each edition of the game and thought of various ways to implement those rules those rules at it applies to their...

Well, I do know there a difference in page presentation and how people view things on screen vs. on paper. One thought, that just occurred to me...I am not as familiar with this site a some other people, but I know when 4E was announced adn this page starting giving rumors and updates about 4E...

Well, this has been one area where my confusion was generated from that I questioned about, because I looked at it in the example the same way that you did. People talk about mechanics and flavor text not mixing in 4E like in previous editions, and not wanting the flavor text "fenced in" but...