Search results

I can see that--"grossly", in retrospect, sets a bad tone. (I meant it in the sense of "I feel that without this the review is incomplete" rather than "you, sir, are a charlatan!" if that makes it any better. Maybe not.) I don't know about cutting anything--you mentioned something about "600...

I'm sorry it came across aggressive--that was completely not my intention. I really was just trying to point out something that I thought would make the review better.

I'm not. I've only played Classic Traveller. That sentence there ^^ I think would have been a good one to have in the original review. I don't know why anyone/no one else has done anything. I believe this is the first review of yours that I've read. When I read it I thought to myself "I wonder...

I'm not asking for an analysis of why RPGs get second editions, I'm suggesting that a simple statement of why this RPG got a second edition. Some RPGs' second editions are minor updates and completely backward-compatible. Other RPGs' second editions are completely different games from their...

Honestly, a 2 or 3. I do feel badly because I don't know the author and feel a little hesitant to criticize a stranger. But I felt it was enough of a deficiency in the review that I'd go ahead and put my name to pointing out where I thought it could be improved. The thing's titled "Adventure in...

Really?! It's the second edition of the first edition Mongoose Traveller rules (2008) that were, in turn based on the Classic Traveller rules (1977). The new edition represents an evolution of these rules rather than a revolution, so they are mostly backwards compatible, and are built with a...

I'm sorry, but a review of a product titled 2e and which is arguably the eleventh edition of a game that doesn't include--or at least link to--any sort of comparison seems grossly inadequate. I could see that this might not be the place for how MGT differs from many other companies'...

I'm so glad you spotted this one and reviewed it--I've played it a bunch with my kids (ranging from 4 to 9) and they love it endlessly. I'll add that it's easy enough to run that I play it with the kids while driving--having them roll into a cupholder. I do disagree with the limit to two...