Goodman's Dungeon Crawl Classics - Which Are Best?

Malvoisin

First Post
I'm considering DMing one of the Dungeon Crawl Classics from Goodman Games, as a one-shot adventure. But, there are so many available now, I have no idea which one(s) are most worthwhile.

Anyone have recommendations (from personal experience or word-of-mouth) as to which are the best? (Could be any level range.)

Thanks!
 

log in or register to remove this ad



Well, it's hard to say which is best unless you have them all. Which I don't. But the only one I didn't like was #14. (But I only have 0,7,14, and 20)
 

I'd say it really depends upon what level you want to run.

For low levels, the updated Idylls of the Rat King (3.5 Edition) is a great one.

I like Aerie of the Crow God a lot. Levels 7-9.

For higher levels, I thought that Crypt of the Devil Lich was a fun one (15th level), but it was similar in vein to Tomb of Horrors. If the PCs survive, they have reason to be proud. :)

There are some people that have planned whoel campaigns from their adventures and the upcoming "DCC World" looks like it will be cool too.
 

I thought that The Lost Vault of Tzthar Rho (sp?) was very good. I used it to start a campaign 2+ years ago, and although I changed the module a fair bit (essentially, I broke the dungeon into 2 separate 'smaller' dungeons, and changed the backstory a fair bit), it worked well.

That is the only DCC that I've actually used. However, I own pdfs for a few more:

The Legacy of the Savage Kings is great. I also like Mysterious Tower (I own the C&C version, but the 3e one is the same except for the stats), and Legends are Made, Not Born. The Dungeon Interludes looks good, as does Legend of the Ripper.
 
Last edited:



I just finished reading #2 - The Lost Vault of Tsathzar Rho and really enjoyed it. Below is a mini-review I wrote for my zine.

Even though the Lost Vault of Tasthzar Rho is an adventure for 1st level characters, newbies need not apply. Third in the Campaign Classics line from Goodman Games, Mike Mearls’ module will be one to remember by those who play it. The setup for the module is simple enough. A once peaceful ogre and kobolds, who dwell in some caves near a village, have recently gone on a rampage. The party is hired to venture to the humanoids’ lair to deal some damage. Upon arrival at the caves, the adventurers will realize that all is not well. For example, the marauding ogre, Logbrag, is described as having black skin, glowing green eyes, and skin that oozes with puss. The kobolds within the caves also appear to have been transformed, appearing with spines jutting from their heads, dragon-like scales, and chanting in a low monotone while in combat.

As the party delves deeper into the cave complex, they soon realize that an alien presence is at work. In one chamber, the party will see walls covered with, “...still-living skin and organs of other creatures captured and warped by the Outer Gods’ servants. Organs pulse, veins throb, and when the characters move close to the walls the skin and body parts move slightly as if reaching out towards the party.” (page 27) Um, did that say “Outer Gods?”

The root of the evil lays with Tsathzar Rho, a wizard who dared tamper with the Outer Gods, alien entities of mind-warping power. When Rho had grown to significant power, the Outer Gods embraced the wizard, transporting he and his underground vaults into a universe of terror. Decades later, the Outer Gods have ejected Rho and his vault back into the Prime Material Plane. Rho’s vault materialized within a cave complex and from the underground lair, his corrupting influence creeps forth.

Running this module requires a DM with a talent for description and narrative, a DM who can build tension and handle chaos. Players need to be skilled role-players as well, willing to sacrifice metagaming in order to immerse themselves in the roles of novice adventurers faced with indescribable horror. While it’d be a challenge to execute well, the Last Vault would be a memorable playing experience.
 

I've bought the following...

> Aerie of the Crow God (good)

> The Sunless Garden (very good concept)

> Curse of the Emerald Cobra (no real opinion, yet)

I've heard good things about "Idylls of the Rat King", but I can't even find a copy of the v.3.5 reprint. I'm definitely going to get "Shadows in Freeport" and, maybe, "Into the Wilds", but not right away.

Cheers!

KF72
 

Remove ads

Top