Menu
News
All News
Dungeons & Dragons
Level Up: Advanced 5th Edition
Pathfinder
Starfinder
Warhammer
2d20 System
Year Zero Engine
Industry News
Reviews
Dragon Reflections
Columns
Weekly Digests
Weekly News Digest
Freebies, Sales & Bundles
RPG Print News
RPG Crowdfunding News
Game Content
ENterplanetary DimENsions
Mythological Figures
Opinion
Worlds of Design
Peregrine's Next
RPG Evolution
Other Columns
From the Freelancing Frontline
Monster ENcyclopedia
WotC/TSR Alumni Look Back
4 Hours w/RSD (Ryan Dancey)
The Road to 3E (Jonathan Tweet)
Greenwood's Realms (Ed Greenwood)
Drawmij's TSR (Jim Ward)
Community
Forums & Topics
Forum List
Latest Posts
Forum list
*Dungeons & Dragons
Level Up: Advanced 5th Edition
D&D Older Editions
*TTRPGs General
*Pathfinder & Starfinder
EN Publishing
*Geek Talk & Media
Search forums
Chat/Discord
Resources
Wiki
Pages
Latest activity
Media
New media
New comments
Search media
Downloads
Latest reviews
Search resources
EN Publishing
Store
EN5ider
Adventures in ZEITGEIST
Awfully Cheerful Engine
What's OLD is NEW
Judge Dredd & The Worlds Of 2000AD
War of the Burning Sky
Level Up: Advanced 5E
Events & Releases
Upcoming Events
Private Events
Featured Events
Socials!
Twitch
YouTube
Facebook (EN Publishing)
Facebook (EN World)
Twitter
Instagram
TikTok
Podcast
Features
Top 5 RPGs Compiled Charts 2004-Present
Adventure Game Industry Market Research Summary (RPGs) V1.0
Ryan Dancey: Acquiring TSR
Q&A With Gary Gygax
D&D Rules FAQs
TSR, WotC, & Paizo: A Comparative History
D&D Pronunciation Guide
Million Dollar TTRPG Kickstarters
Tabletop RPG Podcast Hall of Fame
Eric Noah's Unofficial D&D 3rd Edition News
D&D in the Mainstream
D&D & RPG History
About Morrus
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Forums & Topics
Forum List
Latest Posts
Forum list
*Dungeons & Dragons
Level Up: Advanced 5th Edition
D&D Older Editions
*TTRPGs General
*Pathfinder & Starfinder
EN Publishing
*Geek Talk & Media
Search forums
Chat/Discord
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Community
General Tabletop Discussion
*TTRPGs General
Strange Lands, Lost Tribes of the Scarred Lands
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="JoeGKushner" data-source="post: 2052205" data-attributes="member: 1129"><p><strong>Strange Tribes, Lost Tribes of the Scarred Lands</strong></p><p></p><p>Strange Lands, Lost Tribes of the Scarred Lands, is the last book in the Scarred Lands setting. Clocking in at 288 black and white pages for $34.99, this book focuses on the remaining continents of the Scarred Lands, Asherak, Fenriilik and the Dragon Lands.</p><p></p><p>From a role-playing prospective, it fails. Much of the book is concerned with the game mechanics of those lands and a large section of it, almost one third, is devoted to new monsters, plus an appendix that covers new game mechanics including details for avatars and PrCs that didn’t fit into the other regions.</p><p></p><p>It’s almost like this book is a combination of Relics & Rituals III and Creature Collection IV with a few campaign notes added in for extra measure. How about an example? Well, the book starts with Asherak and not counting the map or the page and a half of handwritten details, it’s just fewer than eighteen pages. Now that doesn’t count the new race, the Wrack Elves or the Ubantu, it doesn’t count the prestige classes like the Acolyte of the Shell, a survivor of the harsh wastelands of Asherak or the Adept of the Rent Shield, spellcasters who worship Vangal and gain access to the Destruction Domain or the Avatar of Chaos, divine spellcasters who worship Enkili, or members of the Unseen Eye, clergy that operate as hidden police of the feats of the land, nor all of chapter two, magic of the wasteland, which includes new equipment magic items, spells, and rituals.</p><p></p><p>The point being is that there are 18 pages of background with perhaps twice as much in terms of game mechanics, do not make for a detailed campaign setting in brand new territories. Now the game mechanics aren’t all details, and some do refer to campaign elements but for the most part, I see no reason why things like Bound Weapons, weapons where outsiders have been fused into a weapon, would only be native to Asherak or why feats like Primal Might, where the druid calls upon the power of Scarn itself to augment their Strength and/or Constitution scores, wouldn’t be applicable for other areas of the setting.</p><p></p><p>The short view of these lands is as follows. Asherak is highly religious with several gods unknown elsewhere, but is a wasteland. Long ago some terrible event almost destroyed the lands. The Land of the Wyrms has lots of dragons and the humanoid societies are given broad strokes of Samurai culture. Fenrilik, the least of these lands with some odd five pages of background, is a frozen wasteland. Ironically enough, I feel that due to products like Frost & Fur by Monkeygod and Frostburn by Wizards of the Coast, it’s probably the easiest to expand and the quickest to take advantage of some potentially unused game mechanics.</p><p></p><p>So what about the monsters? Well, one failure is that there’s no master list of creatures so you can’t quickly see what the CR ranges are or what page number something is on. The artwork varies tremendously. Some of it by RJT is top notch and is joined by fan favorites like Eric Lofgren and another artist, whose name I can’t read, but who adds power to illustrations like the Canopy Drake, Ashwyrm, and the Undying Prince Suuvarros. Others though, I can’t imagine someone going, “Yeah, that’s good, go with it.” For example, the King’s Hound on page 155. Man, someone put that dog out of it’s misery eh? Or the nebulous Wind Demon that looks like a fifth grader quickly sketched it. </p><p></p><p>Overall, the monsters have some good details and descriptions to them. Several unique creatures are included like Gommog, a unique giant-dragon who clocks in at CR of 15. He has a bad that he throws his victims into and then smashes the bag. Others like the Demon Prince Suvarros aren’t quite as cool as their official counter parts like Orcus, but do a nice job of filling up those upper levels of villain. Strangely, one of the more interesting monsters, the Dustrack Dragon, has no name of his own despite being the last of his kind.</p><p></p><p>Monsters are broken up by region and generally stay one to a page although there are exceptions. Monsters include all 3.5 stats like base attack and grapple, along with full attack and movement in numbers and number of squares. </p><p></p><p>After the monsters, we get “Gathered Lore” some near sixty pages of new rules. These rules for enhancing a familiar with feats, similar to how Kenzer has done it, and then moves onto spells for familiar such as Shield Familiar, a 3rd level Wizard spell that makes the familiar immune to damage from the character’s own spells, so you never have to worry about lightning bolting your own familiar to Familiar Teleportwhere the caster may teleport to his familiar’s side or have the familiar teleport to the caster.</p><p></p><p>New artifacts are included along with Scarred Lands Avatars. Both have some interesting uses, but for some, the idea of avatars that differ from the original source, like how Ne Morga now has several different faces like Kadeshu, Otossal and others, to the returned Jandaveos.</p><p></p><p>A few other monsters are included here, which is okay, but a little odd, as they could’ve probably fit elsewhere. The book closes out with three new PrCs. The Prodigalist, an arcane spellcaster who masters his bonds with his familiar, the Shadow Walker, a spellcaster of Drendari, the goddess of shadows, that masters stealth and continues spellcasting at a reduced pace, and the Zathiskan Binder, a spellcaster who binds Genies. </p><p></p><p>The book can be looked at in two ways. One, if you are a loyal Scarred Lands fan and were expecting to see at least 32 pages of clear background material not tied to any game mechanics with a solid map of the world and some sample city maps, you’re going to be crushed. For me, since my SL campaign has died off, the game mechanics in this book will quickly make it into my own campaign. The new monsters have a wide range of CRs. Some of the new magic items are easy to insert into similar themed settings. The spells work well with casters of all types.</p><p></p><p><span style="font-size: 12px"><strong>Reviewer’s Note:</strong> </span> Here’s a breakdown of creatures by name, cr, and page reference.</p><p>Name CR Page</p><p>Dragoneet 1 185</p><p>Wollahog 1 225</p><p>Piradun 1 263</p><p>Dragon Lice 2 177</p><p>Golem, Bamboo 2 188</p><p>Sand Serpent 2 161</p><p>Spitter Newt 2 197</p><p>Ashworm 3 171</p><p>Cactus Imp 3 131</p><p>Dreamthief 3 149</p><p>Frost Maiden 3 206</p><p>Frost Moth 3 207</p><p>Laughing Drake 3 192</p><p>Rock Burbear 3 266</p><p>Dire Camel 4 145</p><p>Glaciad 4 212</p><p>Razor Eel 4 195</p><p>Shimmer Snake 4 220</p><p>Sprite, Iccree 4 213</p><p>Ghoul Ooze 5 186</p><p>Kelklic Sand Beetle 5 154</p><p>Swarm, Godfly 5 165</p><p>Wisp Drake 5 201</p><p>Blood Gardener 6 202</p><p>Boneweed 6 173</p><p>Daemon, Beguiling Merchant 6 133</p><p>Demon, Oculus 6 138</p><p>Devil Ray 6 175</p><p>Fossil Ghoul 6 151</p><p>King’s Hound 6 155</p><p>Mountain Nautilus 6 194</p><p>Storm Harvester 6 198</p><p>Void Wight 6 169</p><p>Darkmoon Slayer 7 135</p><p>Ice Warden 7 216</p><p>Panacea Spirit 7 159</p><p>Rekirrac 7 218</p><p>Skerrai 7 221</p><p>Swarm, Drought Beetle 7 164</p><p>Winter Wraith 7 224</p><p>Canopy Drake 8 174</p><p>Serpent Spy 8 196</p><p>Stealer of Children 8 162</p><p>Glass Scorpion 9 152</p><p>Daemon, Eyethief 11 134</p><p>Garamond 11 209</p><p>Rime Witch 11 219</p><p>Swarm, Voracious Fang 11 166</p><p>Devil, Academician 12 141</p><p>Drowning Hole 12 150</p><p>Fell Deer 12 205</p><p>Babroline 12 208</p><p>Sand Eagle 12 160</p><p>Gelidiceph 13 211</p><p>Snowstorm Elemental 13 223</p><p>Swarm, Wind Demon 13 167</p><p>Unholy Chorus 13 168</p><p>Avion 14 172</p><p>Brince Dragon 14 179</p><p>Demon, Bellowing 14 137</p><p>Dragavial 14 176</p><p>Dragon, Fireglare 14 181</p><p>Giant, Ophidic 14 187</p><p>Gommog 15 191</p><p>Ice Phoenix 15 214</p><p>Na’Heem Sample 15 157</p><p>Devil, Diabolic Enforcer 16 143</p><p>Dragon Snake 17 178</p><p>Divine Envoy 18 146</p><p>Dragon, Dustwrack 18 147</p><p>Golem, Mountain 18 189</p><p>Gorjada 19 153</p><p>Valuga 19 199</p><p>Crawling Glacier 23 204</p><p>Demon, Suvarros 24 139</p><p>Nether Dragon 26 183</p><p></p><p>Templates</p><p>Rock Goblin +1 266</p><p>Nether Dragon +2 184</p><p>Na’heem +4 157</p><p>Aquan Creatures V 268</p><p>Auran V 269</p><p>Exemplar V 270</p><p>Ignan V 271</p><p>Pandemoniac V 272</p><p>Terran V 273</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="JoeGKushner, post: 2052205, member: 1129"] [b]Strange Tribes, Lost Tribes of the Scarred Lands[/b] Strange Lands, Lost Tribes of the Scarred Lands, is the last book in the Scarred Lands setting. Clocking in at 288 black and white pages for $34.99, this book focuses on the remaining continents of the Scarred Lands, Asherak, Fenriilik and the Dragon Lands. From a role-playing prospective, it fails. Much of the book is concerned with the game mechanics of those lands and a large section of it, almost one third, is devoted to new monsters, plus an appendix that covers new game mechanics including details for avatars and PrCs that didn’t fit into the other regions. It’s almost like this book is a combination of Relics & Rituals III and Creature Collection IV with a few campaign notes added in for extra measure. How about an example? Well, the book starts with Asherak and not counting the map or the page and a half of handwritten details, it’s just fewer than eighteen pages. Now that doesn’t count the new race, the Wrack Elves or the Ubantu, it doesn’t count the prestige classes like the Acolyte of the Shell, a survivor of the harsh wastelands of Asherak or the Adept of the Rent Shield, spellcasters who worship Vangal and gain access to the Destruction Domain or the Avatar of Chaos, divine spellcasters who worship Enkili, or members of the Unseen Eye, clergy that operate as hidden police of the feats of the land, nor all of chapter two, magic of the wasteland, which includes new equipment magic items, spells, and rituals. The point being is that there are 18 pages of background with perhaps twice as much in terms of game mechanics, do not make for a detailed campaign setting in brand new territories. Now the game mechanics aren’t all details, and some do refer to campaign elements but for the most part, I see no reason why things like Bound Weapons, weapons where outsiders have been fused into a weapon, would only be native to Asherak or why feats like Primal Might, where the druid calls upon the power of Scarn itself to augment their Strength and/or Constitution scores, wouldn’t be applicable for other areas of the setting. The short view of these lands is as follows. Asherak is highly religious with several gods unknown elsewhere, but is a wasteland. Long ago some terrible event almost destroyed the lands. The Land of the Wyrms has lots of dragons and the humanoid societies are given broad strokes of Samurai culture. Fenrilik, the least of these lands with some odd five pages of background, is a frozen wasteland. Ironically enough, I feel that due to products like Frost & Fur by Monkeygod and Frostburn by Wizards of the Coast, it’s probably the easiest to expand and the quickest to take advantage of some potentially unused game mechanics. So what about the monsters? Well, one failure is that there’s no master list of creatures so you can’t quickly see what the CR ranges are or what page number something is on. The artwork varies tremendously. Some of it by RJT is top notch and is joined by fan favorites like Eric Lofgren and another artist, whose name I can’t read, but who adds power to illustrations like the Canopy Drake, Ashwyrm, and the Undying Prince Suuvarros. Others though, I can’t imagine someone going, “Yeah, that’s good, go with it.” For example, the King’s Hound on page 155. Man, someone put that dog out of it’s misery eh? Or the nebulous Wind Demon that looks like a fifth grader quickly sketched it. Overall, the monsters have some good details and descriptions to them. Several unique creatures are included like Gommog, a unique giant-dragon who clocks in at CR of 15. He has a bad that he throws his victims into and then smashes the bag. Others like the Demon Prince Suvarros aren’t quite as cool as their official counter parts like Orcus, but do a nice job of filling up those upper levels of villain. Strangely, one of the more interesting monsters, the Dustrack Dragon, has no name of his own despite being the last of his kind. Monsters are broken up by region and generally stay one to a page although there are exceptions. Monsters include all 3.5 stats like base attack and grapple, along with full attack and movement in numbers and number of squares. After the monsters, we get “Gathered Lore” some near sixty pages of new rules. These rules for enhancing a familiar with feats, similar to how Kenzer has done it, and then moves onto spells for familiar such as Shield Familiar, a 3rd level Wizard spell that makes the familiar immune to damage from the character’s own spells, so you never have to worry about lightning bolting your own familiar to Familiar Teleportwhere the caster may teleport to his familiar’s side or have the familiar teleport to the caster. New artifacts are included along with Scarred Lands Avatars. Both have some interesting uses, but for some, the idea of avatars that differ from the original source, like how Ne Morga now has several different faces like Kadeshu, Otossal and others, to the returned Jandaveos. A few other monsters are included here, which is okay, but a little odd, as they could’ve probably fit elsewhere. The book closes out with three new PrCs. The Prodigalist, an arcane spellcaster who masters his bonds with his familiar, the Shadow Walker, a spellcaster of Drendari, the goddess of shadows, that masters stealth and continues spellcasting at a reduced pace, and the Zathiskan Binder, a spellcaster who binds Genies. The book can be looked at in two ways. One, if you are a loyal Scarred Lands fan and were expecting to see at least 32 pages of clear background material not tied to any game mechanics with a solid map of the world and some sample city maps, you’re going to be crushed. For me, since my SL campaign has died off, the game mechanics in this book will quickly make it into my own campaign. The new monsters have a wide range of CRs. Some of the new magic items are easy to insert into similar themed settings. The spells work well with casters of all types. [SIZE=3][B]Reviewer’s Note:[/B] [/SIZE] Here’s a breakdown of creatures by name, cr, and page reference. Name CR Page Dragoneet 1 185 Wollahog 1 225 Piradun 1 263 Dragon Lice 2 177 Golem, Bamboo 2 188 Sand Serpent 2 161 Spitter Newt 2 197 Ashworm 3 171 Cactus Imp 3 131 Dreamthief 3 149 Frost Maiden 3 206 Frost Moth 3 207 Laughing Drake 3 192 Rock Burbear 3 266 Dire Camel 4 145 Glaciad 4 212 Razor Eel 4 195 Shimmer Snake 4 220 Sprite, Iccree 4 213 Ghoul Ooze 5 186 Kelklic Sand Beetle 5 154 Swarm, Godfly 5 165 Wisp Drake 5 201 Blood Gardener 6 202 Boneweed 6 173 Daemon, Beguiling Merchant 6 133 Demon, Oculus 6 138 Devil Ray 6 175 Fossil Ghoul 6 151 King’s Hound 6 155 Mountain Nautilus 6 194 Storm Harvester 6 198 Void Wight 6 169 Darkmoon Slayer 7 135 Ice Warden 7 216 Panacea Spirit 7 159 Rekirrac 7 218 Skerrai 7 221 Swarm, Drought Beetle 7 164 Winter Wraith 7 224 Canopy Drake 8 174 Serpent Spy 8 196 Stealer of Children 8 162 Glass Scorpion 9 152 Daemon, Eyethief 11 134 Garamond 11 209 Rime Witch 11 219 Swarm, Voracious Fang 11 166 Devil, Academician 12 141 Drowning Hole 12 150 Fell Deer 12 205 Babroline 12 208 Sand Eagle 12 160 Gelidiceph 13 211 Snowstorm Elemental 13 223 Swarm, Wind Demon 13 167 Unholy Chorus 13 168 Avion 14 172 Brince Dragon 14 179 Demon, Bellowing 14 137 Dragavial 14 176 Dragon, Fireglare 14 181 Giant, Ophidic 14 187 Gommog 15 191 Ice Phoenix 15 214 Na’Heem Sample 15 157 Devil, Diabolic Enforcer 16 143 Dragon Snake 17 178 Divine Envoy 18 146 Dragon, Dustwrack 18 147 Golem, Mountain 18 189 Gorjada 19 153 Valuga 19 199 Crawling Glacier 23 204 Demon, Suvarros 24 139 Nether Dragon 26 183 Templates Rock Goblin +1 266 Nether Dragon +2 184 Na’heem +4 157 Aquan Creatures V 268 Auran V 269 Exemplar V 270 Ignan V 271 Pandemoniac V 272 Terran V 273 [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Post reply
Community
General Tabletop Discussion
*TTRPGs General
Strange Lands, Lost Tribes of the Scarred Lands
Top