delericho
Legend
The jist of my statement is that after witnessing uselessness, they would have accepted a monster over that.
Sure, the LG paladin probably would have been better, unless it tried to prevent the party from being profitable!
Aye, but that's the problem - for any evil character you care to present there's always a good character who would be just as effective. So simply saying "I can kill creatures really well" isn't really enough. Better to come up with some other rationale for the evil character sticking with the group - maybe he's a relative of another PC, or he has unique information that they need, or the party's employer instructs them to work with him, or something.