D&D 5E Xanathar's Elven Accuracy

FrogReaver said:

Also consider, it's still a solid feat choice for classes that can gain advantage in certain circumstances, rogue assassain, arcane trickster, certain clerics, samurai ability, battlemaster prone ability, gloomstalker ranger, the new magic weapon generating spell (forget the name).

Click to expand...

EvanNave55 said:

Do you mean Shadow Blade? 2nd level spell makes a blade of shadow and among other benefits you have advantage to attack with it in dim light or darkness.

Click to expand...

Horwath said:

Well, it's not that big of a bonus.

But it comes with +1 ability boost so the feat is fine.

Advantage 2d20-drop lowest gives 13,82 average over 10,50 of 1d20. A 3,32 bonus.

Elven accuracy(improved advantage), basicaly 3d20 drop 2 lowest, gives; 15,49 average. 1,67 bonus over advantage.

That is +1,67 bonus to attack if and when you have advantage.

Click to expand...

FrogReaver said:

At 50% chance to hit advantage is like a +5. At 40% and 60% chance to hit it's just a little worse than +5 to hit. At 30% and 70% chance to hit it's a little better than +4. At 20% and 80% it's a little better than +3. At 10% and 90% it's a little worse than +2 to hit but still better than +1.67 to hit.

So I call shenanigans. Apparently your average dice roll differences doesn't tell you the average to hit differences. Knowing what you are computing is important...

Click to expand...

FrogReaver said:

I'm happy they fixed many of the biggest offenders with the Elven accuracy feat by allowing it to work with almost every type of attack except strength attacks.

So far I've found 3 very good uses for the feat I like now.

1. Open Fist Monk with Elven Accuracy. All your attacks are dex attacks and you anytime you flurry you can prone with a dex save (assuming one of the attacks hit). At level 5 you would really come online with super advantage on many attacks.

2. Warlock + Darkness trick using either eldritch blast or weapon attacks.

3. A paladin X / rogue 1 / champion 3 for crit fishing. DualWield for a bonus action attack and attempt to prone with it. Rogue gives an extra damage dice and athletics expertise for the prone attempt. Paladin gives smites that can be saved to be used on a crit.

Also consider, it's still a solid feat choice for classes that can gain advantage in certain circumstances, rogue assassain, arcane trickster, certain clerics, samurai ability, battlemaster prone ability, gloomstalker ranger, the new magic weapon generating spell (Shadow Blade).

Also, in the right parties it could be an absolutely devastating feat choice. In parties that already grant a lot of advantage.

Did I forget any other good pairings?

Are any of the pairing I called out exceptionally good and better than the others?

Click to expand...

Horwath said:

I'm talking about overall chance from needing 20 to needing 1 to hit.

Also +1,67 is bonus of elven accuracy over already present advantage.

Advantage alone gives average +3,32 bonus over normal d20 roll.

elven accuracy gives total +5 bonus over normal 1d20 roll.

Click to expand...

Coroc said:

Of those builds I only would allow 1. at my table eventually 2. cannot analyse at the moment, the third is for my personal taste an absolute munchkin build.

If a pala at my table decides to take rogue as a second class he is in for a check whether he has fallen and lost all his pally powers. Same goes to change to a fighter fighter.

A pally strives to be pure and devoted, it is imho pure minmax powergaming to multiclass a paladin for any other than highly plot/rp justified reasons.

Click to expand...