My all-time favorite D&D book ever. I love this thing. I got it new when it first came out and have had a few copies over the years as others were lost or wore out.
Rules Cyclopedia Of Basic D&D Now In Print
My all-time favorite D&D book ever. I love this thing. I got it new when it first came out and have had a few copies over the years as others were lost or wore out.
mach1.9pants
Hero
Jeez hard to say, but B/X goes to level 14, and doesn't include much extras. Well written, for the time, and covers all the basics (classes, equip, magic items, monsters). Thieves max out at level 14, with the idea of new abilities in the never written Companion set (heaps of OSR have made a B/X Companion tho). A Map of Karamerikos with a bit of info
BECMI/RC has a lot of extra, new classes (Druid, Monk), sub classes (Paladin, etc), more and in depth rules on all the good DnD stuff (water travel, planar travel, strongholds, mass combat), attack ranks for demi-humans (cos humans go all the way to 36), weapon mastery making Fighters way better, a ton more monsters, spells (incl level 7 up) and magic items. The Thief gets screwed as his already pathetic skills chances are dragged out over double or more levels, saves are dragged out for everyone. More maps of The Known World (laterly known as Mystara) and more info on different areas.
B/X has got all you need (think 5E basic rules) BECMI/RC has the PHB, DMG, MM, Volo, XGtE, etc
Last edited by a moderator:
hedgeknight
Explorer
This news makes me very happy! Like an idiot, I sold my only copy a few years ago and have regretted it since. And the prices for one on "Feebay" are ridiculous. Happy gaming, folks!
Ath-kethin
Elder Thing
Thank you
... now could someone 5e-ify this set of rules...
Hmm. Interesting idea.
I would actually argue that 5e is this-ifying the last couple of editions' sets of rules.
Myrdin Potter
Hero
I never played this, I had the original blue box basic rules and then bought the AD&D books and never looked back. There are so many retro clones out there that use these rules that they also have been generally available. I still bought the POD hardcover just to have the original rules all in one place. I also now own the 0D&D rule vooksmthat I slowly picked up over time.
The write up above? Aaron's name is mentioned three times at least?
I believe that BX might mean Basic and expert editions? Bas was introductory and was meant for play at very low levels. Expert was for experienced players. The BECMI, I think may have revised rules, but I know it was developed by Frank Metzner. This included the Basic and Experts (BE) and Companion and Masters (CM). The C and M were for veterans with high experience levels (up 36th level)!
Immortal was something completely different, as Frank decided make Immortals playable characters. There were two ways to get an Immortal character your high level character can attempt to get his Immortal to sponsor him, or the DM can just let you role one up. Regular mortal characters can attain up to 36th level, but Immortals were NOT 37th level and higher.
Nope they were an entirely different kind of player character altogether.
Of course then Aaron Allston came along and revised things further with the Rules Cyclopedia, which was equivalent to a hardcopy BECM. The Immortals part was replaced with Wrath of the Immortals rulebook.
Zardnaar
Legend
B/X is basic and expert pre mentzer, BECMI for example nerfed the thief for example stretching out the skills over 36 levels while the old thief got high skills by level 14. Nerfing the weakest class.........
Also level 14 is a nice end point for D&D and the MI part in particular may as well have not existed.
Similar Threads
D&D General
The abandoned core monsters of D&D
D&D General
The core monster lineup across all editions