LadyLaw
First Post
Although it seems overpowered, if it were my game I'd rule that each die could turn out no less than 3 (so 6 total) because it actually says a result of 3 on the "die," which refers to only 1 object. As each die in a 2d4 is a separate object, I would treat them separately. However, that may not be the actual intention of the feat.
Taken from another perspective, if you crit, would you count a 1 or 2 on your crit die as a 3? What about if it wasn't a falchion but a greatsword, and you used an attack that allowed for 2[W] damage? Would each of those dice be taken separately? (I would say so.) If the answer is yes, then I think the same should apply to each of the 2d4 for a falchion. However, I do think that's a bit powerful, so I can see how it might get ruled differently.
Taken from another perspective, if you crit, would you count a 1 or 2 on your crit die as a 3? What about if it wasn't a falchion but a greatsword, and you used an attack that allowed for 2[W] damage? Would each of those dice be taken separately? (I would say so.) If the answer is yes, then I think the same should apply to each of the 2d4 for a falchion. However, I do think that's a bit powerful, so I can see how it might get ruled differently.