The Prequels, Episodes I-III. What did you like about them?

MechaPilot

Explorer
Wait until you see The Force Awakens. You haven't seen a lightsaber duel until you've seen that film. For the first time, in any Star Wars film, the sabers are presented as the horrible, gritty, deadly, weapons of death that they are. The lightsaber fights are vicious.

I have to disagree with that. The lightsaber duels in TFA felt to me like a middle-ground between the "actors lazily poking at each other" of the original trilogy and the extremely choreographed battles of the prequels. That said, the story of TFA did a better job of setting things up so that each of the duels felt like they really had serious stakes than the prequels did.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Water Bob

Adventurer
I have to disagree with that. The lightsaber duels in TFA felt to me like a middle-ground between the "actors lazily poking at each other" of the original trilogy and the extremely choreographed battles of the prequels. That said, the story of TFA did a better job of setting things up so that each of the duels felt like they really had serious stakes than the prequels did.

Yeah, I can't agree. The prequel saber fights, to me, looked like the actors just swinging handles around anywhere they wanted, and the CGI folks drew in their strokes later, based on the actor's movement. They never felt like weapons the way they did in the original trilogy, and especially in the new movie.
 

Morrus

Well, that was fun
Staff member
I found the prequel fights to be soulless dances. They had little emotion. The fight at the end of Ep VI may not have been ballet, but it was captivating watching. Full of raw emotion.
 

MechaPilot

Explorer
I found the prequel fights to be soulless dances. They had little emotion. The fight at the end of Ep VI may not have been ballet, but it was captivating watching. Full of raw emotion.

The fight at the end of VI was probably the best one of the original trilogy. Although I do think that's due to the stakes that were placed on it by the story. I think the fight in Cloud City in Empire was probably the best one from the perspective of looking at the technical aspects of the fight.
 

Morrus

Well, that was fun
Staff member
The fight at the end of VI was probably the best one of the original trilogy. Although I do think that's due to the stakes that were placed on it by the story. I think the fight in Cloud City in Empire was probably the best one from the perspective of looking at the technical aspects of the fight.

There were only three. The Empire and Jedi ones were both great. The New Hope one? Alec Guinness was an old man!
 

Darth Maul. Needs to return in the movies

Explanation of Clone Wars for those of us that never read the novels

General Greivious (sp). bad a$$ and he wasn't even a jedi
 

darjr

I crit!
I think I'd have to go back and watch them again, and I don't want to do that. But I do remember liking the lightsaber battles, though I agree they are mostly soulless. The first one was my favorite and I remember thinking it was dumb killing off Darth Maul. For me he wasn't menacing but radiated raw rage and hate. When I first saw him I was looking forward to the emperor having to fight and kill him because he'd screw something up too many times just to vent his hate. That would have been interesting.

Also I remember loving the idea of a Clone war. I thought it would include clones of Jedi and senators. Imagining Jedi fighting Jedi and never really knowing if it was a turned Jedi or a clone. But then it wasn't that.
 

Eltab

Lord of the Hidden Layer
1. Darth Maul's costume, makeup, and double-ended lightsaber. He _looked_ like a Sith assassin. He should not have been the Sith Apprentice but Sidious' enforcer, taught some Force talents to make him more dangerous.

2. Rise of the Emperor, and his manipulation of Galactic politics so that nobody (but him) could get anything done. Too bad most of this only came out via Palpatine's "special Dark Lord of the Sith power: Makes plot commentary for the audience's benefit, in front of characters who have no business knowing what he's really up to and don't take the hints anyway"

3. Jedi moral dilemma: do we help the suffering people in front of us, or stick with The Master Plan (tm) that requires we get somewhere else asap? (Slavery on Tatooine, which is both immoral in and of itself, plus unlawful under the Republic.)
3a. Qui-Jon having to 'tilt the odds' when he realizes he can get only one person - Anakin or Shmi - away from their owner

4. Anakin as a rebellious Padawan, obviously striving against Obi-Wan more than he is learning anything. This helps set up some comments and background in the other movies.


Of course, all these come with a heavy dose of "what might have been".
1) Introducing and then killing Darth Maul in the same movie was a waste of a good character concept
1a) If one blade is good, two is better. If two is good, four is twice as good, right? ... umm, maybe not. Grevious was hard to watch and understand what he was doing with all those whirling blades. (Helicopters or shields are not as impressive as "rub your tummy and pat your head" at the same time. Anakin does this right for a little bit when chasing Dooku.)

2) Anakin and Padme's abortive and clunky discussion of politics should have flowed from a discussion of difficult negotiations, not his impatience with results.

3) Really - the Good Guys of the Galaxy have NO IDEA that the Republic is in distress - they are too busy meditating on the Balance of the Force - and no amount of reports from the field can break through the fog ?!

4) Also nobody notices that the Knight / Padawan relationship is already in tatters, nor does anybody offer to take Anakin off Obi-Wan's obviously overburdened / befuddled hands. Mace Windu would have been a better Master for Anakin, because he could pound Anakin into the pavement as the beginning of teaching him how to respect people with lesser talents than his own.
 

Morrus

Well, that was fun
Staff member
I'm trying to think what I thought the clone wars were like before the prequels came out. Back when all we had was a mention in ANH.
 

MarkB

Legend
I'm trying to think what I thought the clone wars were like before the prequels came out. Back when all we had was a mention in ANH.

For one thing, I always imagined it as a series of conflicts, perhaps over decades. A single massive conflict, even on a galactic scale, doesn't really earn the plural.
 

Remove ads

Top