John R Davis
Hero
No. It really is complicated other wise the progressive Bill brought into law in Scotland that is not going to work well, in the small % of cases, would be fineI'm not sure it is that complicated. Surely prisons have dealt before with cis-gendered prisoners who have a history of sex crimes against same sex victims.
Sports can and should be dealt with on a sport-by-sport basis under the leadership of each sport's governing body.
But a significant part of the issue here is tarring every trans woman with the same brush as a very small percent of cases, no matter how sensationalized they have been by the press. Don't trans women deserve safer spaces than the male-dominated ones they no longer identify with and may, outwardly, no longer resemble?
The concern is not the trans-person, who in theory is protected by the same law as everyone else, trans rights are human rights BUT the predator who would be able to access areas they shouldn't and are a real threat to women's safety ( safety they have fought bloody hard for over the decades).
I don't know the answer. It is complicated so I can see both sides arguement. It is the minority cases that test law the most.