Rabbitbait
Grog-nerd
Does it inspire me? If not, there is no point in going any further.
If it does, then I start looking at:
The last WOTC adventure that ticked enough of those boxes for me was Temple of Annihilation. That was a goodie. It only really failed on the character arcs for me (partly because it was mostly in the jungle, partly because everyone kept dying).
If it does, then I start looking at:
- how coherent is it?
- how flexible is it?
- can I easily change it without breaking it
- does it give room for character arcs
- can I insert it into different worlds
The last WOTC adventure that ticked enough of those boxes for me was Temple of Annihilation. That was a goodie. It only really failed on the character arcs for me (partly because it was mostly in the jungle, partly because everyone kept dying).