Recent content by Micah Sweet

  1. Micah Sweet

    Level Up (A5E) A5E System Reference Document (A5ESRD)

    Yeah. I'm in the US and haven't seen it yet. Thought it would still be a bit.
  2. Micah Sweet

    Game Balance, what is it to you, why is it important, and what if you all but threw it out?

    Let me just say I disagree, and feel realism in gaming has been successfully done in many areas in different games, even versions of D&D to some degree. I don't think I misunderstood you. I think you are stating your personal opinion about simulation in an RPG context and claiming it is...
  3. Micah Sweet

    Game Balance, what is it to you, why is it important, and what if you all but threw it out?

    1. Fantasy does not automatically mean all sense of verisimilitude is meaningless and literally anything goes. It certainly doesn't mean that anyone who disagrees with you on the subject is pursuing a "fool's folly", and suggesting otherwise is dangerously close to declaring other people's fun...
  4. Micah Sweet

    Ken Burns' The American Revolution

    Just heard about this recently. Looking forward to watching it myself.
  5. Micah Sweet

    Modules: Made to Read vs Made to Run?

    HTML might be better for some people in actual play at the table, but PDF works great for reading and reference, which are the main reasons I use books. And it is just as good for electronic storage and transport as HTML, while not requiring an internet connection or subscription (which HTML...
  6. Micah Sweet

    TSR On the Relative Merits of the TSR Editions

    Sorry about that. I'm careful about not stating that my preferences are better than others, and I really believe that, but I do think they're better for me; or I would prefer something else, and I have no interest in pretending otherwise. For me, worldbuilding and design, and especially the...
  7. Micah Sweet

    TSR On the Relative Merits of the TSR Editions

    What kind of game do you think a game with a longer character generation time is? I don't see how that metric has any effect on a game's status as an RPG. As far as rules mastery and introducing new players goes, obviously it's personal preference but I have no problem taking my time and easing...
  8. Micah Sweet

    TSR On the Relative Merits of the TSR Editions

    I suppose, but if you want a character with lots of mechanical widgets (which apparently isn't a deal breaker for a lot of gamers, judging from the popularity of modern D&D and its relatives), then character creation is just going to take a little more time. If you're worried about getting a new...
  9. Micah Sweet

    Shadowdark Shadowdark General Thread [+]

    As I said, I don't see the systems being so different that you can't just make any needed conversions, thus preserving the flavor.
  10. Micah Sweet

    Shadowdark Shadowdark General Thread [+]

    Maybe so, but is the setting really so different that any needed conversion can't be handled by the GM?
  11. Micah Sweet

    Are You A GM?

    I've been the GM more often than not (and prefer it that way) since 2018, but before that was a round-robin situation in my old group. Nowadays I'm happy to sit behind the screen unless someone in the group gets a wild hair.
  12. Micah Sweet

    TSR On the Relative Merits of the TSR Editions

    I've never understood the problem with taking more time to make a character. That's a big part of what session zero is for, after all. Take all the time you need I say.
  13. Micah Sweet

    D&D General [+] More Robust 'Fantasy Race' Mechanics for D&D-alikes / Redeeming 'Race as Class' for Modern D&D [+]

    That sounds like reflavoring. I know this is a good solution for many people, but I have never been in favor of it. For me, if you are simulating different things they should be represented differently in the rules.
  14. Micah Sweet

    Who Should Gal Gadot Play In The New DCU?

    Are they rebooting the DCCU then? I hadn't heard that, but I'm not surprised. It hasn't been as successful at the end of the day as they'd hoped, and full continuity reboots are still all the rage in the DCU(s).
  15. Micah Sweet

    Worlds of Design: Story vs. Gameplay

    Yup. I definitely don't want the mechanics to push any more story than that. That's up to the players and how they choose to interact with the setting through their PCs IMO.
Top