Recent content by Reyemile

Honestly? I don't believe you. It sounds good and tough to say things like that, but DMs who actually say "sorry, you picked up the FAKE MacGuffin of Doom, not the real one. World blows up. New campaign?" tend not to stay DMs for very long.

Personally, I hate "you need to save the world" stories for metagame reasons. When the whole world/universe is at stake, its basically a given that the PCs will win. The end of the world, after all, would also be the end of the campaign. On the other hand, "save the region" or even "save the...

If Armor Class makes you harder to hurt, not to hit, then why do we refer to a low roll as a miss ​in the first place?

Define "balanced alternative?" From my perspective, daily-only resource mechanics are inherently impossible to balance against encounter-based mechanics; any solution will be unbalanced by default. So, given that, just make up something that sounds like it would be fun for the type of people who...

This sounds very much like Legends D20. It does almost exactly this.

*I* did no such thing. You're getting posters confused

"Railroad" might have been a poor explanation here. I think it's more accurate to call 4e "D&D tactics" because your powers are tactical as opposed to strategic. For me, 4e games were more story-driven in the sense that players are less likely to bypass a story completely just by using elements...

Actually, significantly more than other ranged characters; as long as clerics have ranged 5 powers and a burst-5 healing word, it will be a lot easier for monsters to engage them than the longbow-Ranger hiding 20 squares away behind a tree.

Is it just me, or does the Magma Eruptions feat do basically nothing? Stare at the Sun seems close to useless as well...

And by sorcerer, you mean beguiler, so you only have to worry about your Int mod and not your Charisma, right? Right? :-)

Not to defend the system--it's horribly unbalanced--but actually using a CR3 monster as a level 3 pac was broken. That's because of soemthing they learned and changed into 4e: monsters can have tons of out-of-combat abilities that have NOTHING to do with combat. Charm Person at will, for...

What's important is threefold: first, that the 13 year old learn that actions have consequences and that just being totally crazy will eventually bite him; second, that those consequence be in-game and that you're not trying to punish him for his creativity; and third, that he isn't bothering...

MnM's on my list, too; unfortunately, of the two groups I game with, one is married to Hero (which works fine too) and the other can't handle the complication. Burning Wheel looked really fun, but has a few things--notably its insane combat system--that kept me from ever actually running it...

Darn, I was hoping that no one else had mentioned improve so I could sound all smart and awesome for suggesting it. Foiled again! That being said, Improv classes at summer camp are responsible for much of my DMing skills, as well as my teaching ability (my day job)

Hi Pielorhino, I am in a similar group. We've specifically tossed a rules-heavy system in favor of more narrative approach, and we routinely houserule to manage things that have gotten over--or under--powered. The difference in our points of view has to do with your original quote: you said...