Search results

  1. Ydars

    WotC Backs Down: Original OGL To Be Left Untouched; Whole 5E Rules Released as Creative Commons

    You are quite correct. Many WoTC staffers leaked the OGL plans to a YouTuber called DnDShorts and he and Linda Codega broke the story. They also told us alot more information about the internal workings at WoTC. The person to blame for all this is Chris Cao...
  2. Ydars

    WotC Backs Down: Original OGL To Be Left Untouched; Whole 5E Rules Released as Creative Commons

    You cannot combine them and it won't help you with that even if you did. Mind Flayers and setting material (FR, Greyhawlk etc) are not in either the OGL or SRD 5.1, so there is no way to do that for One D&D or even 5e once they close the DM's Guild (and I assume they will).
  3. Ydars

    WotC Backs Down: Original OGL To Be Left Untouched; Whole 5E Rules Released as Creative Commons

    So now they make One D&D completely incompatible with 5e and release no 3rd party license for creators for it. So they get their walled garden but by a different means. Cos this is all just about 5e and previous editions. They will move us all onto One D&D and then the cycle starts all over...
  4. Ydars

    D&D 5E Low Level Wizards Really Do Suck in 5E

    Just read the whole discussion and have to say that I largely agree with KD; low level wizards are very difficult to play at present, and you really have to be on your game. And I say this from the perspective of someone who used to play the type of Wizard in 3.5E, who used Unseen Servant to...
  5. Ydars

    Religions in D&D

    Hmm; I think you've hit the nail on the head here! Religion is always about magical powers but never specifically about devotion. Not only that but a lot of the D&D stuff is really just lists of deities; no idea about rituals, holy people associated with the religion, ties to any kind of...
  6. Ydars

    Religions in D&D

    I have always wondered why most FRPGs shy away from telling us anything about the religions in our game worlds; I mean religion is one of the most powerful forces in the time period our games are set up to 'faux' model, especially in D&D where we have a cleric class. There's not even any good...
  7. Ydars

    [LORE RPG] Critique this set of mechanics

    Oops; fixed the link! And here's a bit about the design philosophy as well. http://waysider.co.uk/why-your-game-needs-gloamings/ http://www.waysiderpress.com/the-hole-at-the-centre-of-all-f... http://www.waysiderpress.com/it-was-given-to-me-to-know/
  8. Ydars

    [LORE RPG] Critique this set of mechanics

    Hi All! I am writing a Fantasy RPG that is a mix in 'feel' of Ars Magica, Dragon Warriors, Harn and maybe even a bit of Pendragon thrown in. Now we come to the mechanics! Those resemble nothing found in any of those games and I wanted to gather some opinions on them. See here for details...
  9. Ydars

    New site launches for Dragon Warriors and LORE RPG

    Hi all! A new site has just launched that discusses world-building and game design in low magic games and settings; e.g. Dragon Warriors, but there's lots there to chew over for the d20 DM too. http://waysider.co.uk
  10. Ydars

    Dear Mike & Monte

    D&D seems to be played a number of different ways and designing a game that will please everyone is challenging, but I believe it's possible. Couldn't the game be split up into 'meta-tiers' that have different design assumptions? I would propose that the 'prime material plane' be broken into 3...
  11. Ydars

    WotC's Annual Xmas Layoffs

    Oh you were wrong; BadFunWrong!! (joke) Honestly; I had forgotten it was Wyatt who said that stuff online and in the DMG. It is certainly the statement that crystallised for me how far WoTC had taken D&D away from what I thought it was. And yet he is still at WoTC! Do Monte's ramblings worry...
  12. Ydars

    WotC's Annual Xmas Layoffs

    Need you ask (madness is never far away in my case). Seriously though, just because he worked on 4E does not mean Baker backed every single thing it represents; I blame Mearls, Wyatt and Slavisek for the problems in the 'design philosophy' of 4E that turned me off it. Baker did so many good...
  13. Ydars

    WotC's Annual Xmas Layoffs

    You misunderstand me; I am saying that all business accounting is false accounting because it takes notice only of $ and only in a very narrow time slot. This is obviously wrong but things are set up this way to allow bad practices to continue in the name of 'commerce'. To be a true...
  14. Ydars

    WotC's Annual Xmas Layoffs

    WoTC's decision makes perfect sense; in the mad-as-a-hatter, through-the-looking-glass world that is modern business practice. Remember, this is the same genius mentality that has brought us climate change and the credit crunch, and it is all summed up in one phrase; False accounting! It is...
  15. Ydars

    Flat-Footed

    I too, am glad you have decided to stick to RAW; because not doing so fundamentally changes the balance of the game. Look at it another way; how many combats have you ever seen where each person acted whilst everyone else stood around frozen. That is the way D&D combat works; it is an...
  16. Ydars

    What it’s got in its nassty little pocketses? (101 pickpocketing results)

    Or you could try this great random pocket content generator. http://donjon.bin.sh/random/#purse
  17. Ydars

    Scared of PC Homebrew--Help Please!

    I am nonplussed. Why are you 'scared' of anything any of your players does. YOU are the DM and have the right to say no to anything you are not comfortable with. If you have never DMed before, my first piece of advice is only to allow the feats and classes in the PHB. If your friends are...
  18. Ydars

    Flat-Footed

    There is a reason the state is called 'flat-footed' because in swordplay, if you are not on the balls of your feet and in the correct stance, you cannot move properly to avoid blows or parry and you can't shift your weight to frame a blow of your own safely). Indeed, if you are flat footed, it...
  19. Ydars

    Castles are worthless against armies with mages?

    I also want my games to remain as 'pseudo-medieval' as possible and so use some home-brewed mundune non-magical materials to achieve this. 1) Weaveshatter powder is a non-magical explosive material (worth 4000 gp), made from a number of uncommon components, that when ignited results in a loud...
  20. Ydars

    If you could play in a campaign of your choice, what would it be?

    If I had a WISH (9th level spell) and could play in any campaign, it would be a time-travelling jaunt, back to the Gygax Castle Greyhawk campaign in the 1970s. I wanna get me some Mordenkainen et al.
Top