Search results

  1. M

    D&D 4E 4e Hitpoints are modelled after quantum mechanics

    This is the rule I've been using for zombine rotter minions. Since they are so much worse than other minions, a save vs death makes them feel like zombies should.
  2. M

    XP working as intended?

    Are you running the traps as seperate, complete encounters? If so, they aren't worth the experience award. Traps work best as part of an encounter - like an extra monster. But also, consider the amount of time the players are spending on these 'encounters' - if the traps and skill challenges...
  3. M

    Divine Challenge at the end of your turn

    Actually, as Hypersmurf points out, it's not. Once you understand how it works, it's actually very hard to describe it in as few words as the rulebook does, without seeming even more clunky and open to misinterpretation. Believe me, I've tried. Here's a restatement of the rules for when you can...
  4. M

    Need help with Blade Cascade math

    Here's probably the simplest way to calculate the damage: Hit Chance + Hit Chance ^2 + Hit Chance ^3 + Hit Chance ^4 + Hit Chance ^5 (Hit chance as a percentage, a fraction of 1) Yes, the total can exceed 1. Multiply that by the damage for a single attack.
  5. M

    Monster Manual Stat Bonuses

    He's aware of that. He's pointed out two stats where they don't add up correctly. Actually all the Vampire Spawn bonuses seems to be one point too high.
  6. M

    Combat Challenge & Bulettes At-Will power.

    My earlier answer was obviously wrong - I should have read the Bulette description. But after thinking about this, i think the fighter may well be able to attack. I'm not sure though. Here's waht I'm thinking: The fighter gets its Immediate attack "whenever a marked enemy that is adjacent to...
  7. M

    Combat Challenge & Bulettes At-Will power.

    The attack granted by combat challenge is not an OA. However, that might be irrelevant: The fighter- indeed, anyone - can make an OA attack whenever an enemy leaves an adjacent square. So the fighter gets an OA. If that hits, the bulette stops moving due to the Fighter's Combat Superiority, and...
  8. M

    Divine Challenge at the end of your turn

    It may be hard to believe, but I wasn't using 'threadcrapping' as a perjorative. I apologise to the original poster if it came across as rude, and to anyone else who was offended. I was just stating that discussion about whether the entire thread itself was valid within the thread was a...
  9. M

    Dealing with Healing Surges

    Alternatively, so you don;t have to change the way you play, do the following: Youy get the equivalent of one Extended Rest at the end of each week, for free. In addition, once per week, you can take a 6 hour Rest & Recuperate action to get the same benefit. You can't gain this benefit through...
  10. M

    D&D 4E Bag of Tricks seems to be a look into 4E summoning

    who is francis the badger?
  11. M

    Clarify the Combat Challenge?

    Actually, that's not true. The abilities of Combat Challenge (attack a target who shifts, or attack a target who attacks someone else) only work on a market target. The ability of Combat Superiority (end a target's movement with an OA) can be used whether the target is marked or not.
  12. M

    Clarify the Combat Challenge?

    Yes. No. Combat Challenge does not grant OAs. It grants a special Immediate action, which you can use in only two situations: when an adjacent marked enemy shifts or attacks someone other than you. So, if the kobold ran up alongside you as described, you'd get an OA. If the kobold then stopped...
  13. M

    Collected Core Handbook Errata

    They don't contradict each other, becuase they are for different things. The first is for whether you can see someone - and so use powers which require line of sight. The second is for whether the target has cover when you attack them. A target can have cover, and still be seen - so no...
  14. M

    Divine Challenge at the end of your turn

    It's best to think of the Divine Challenge as a mark, which has extra benefits. This exactly the same as the fighter's mark: it is a mark, with the additional benefit of allowing the fighter to get an extra attack under cirtain circumstances, for instance. So, if the Paladin marks an enemy, the...
  15. M

    Feat-a-day design challenge

    I think this is overpowered. I think it would be okay as a Paragon Feat, if you dropped the skills bonus and just made it a power subsititution feat. Also, it should be a Daily use, so you can only use it once. Edit: actually, i think it's still overpowered. Are you lkimited to powers you...
  16. M

    Questions on Traps (SPOILERS to the DMG-Dungeon)

    While I agree in principle, it seems to me it is also the sort of thing you could use a stunt for (the rules on DMG 42), as long at wasn't as easy as the Thievery approach.
  17. M

    Module Template

    This could be useful, but I suggest creating styles for the various headings, and making sure the heading & text styles for different types of powers/magic items/monsters/etc are included.
  18. M

    Yet Another Take on Page 42

    Paul's suggestion is exactly the one I've been taking. I have Easy, Moderate, and Hard each having different progression.
  19. M

    D&D 4E Class-free 4E

    Most of the worst abuses possible could probably be handled by the following: "The 5-point benefits are exclusive; if you have one of them, you may not have any others."
Top