Search results

My apologies if this has already been covered, as i didn't have time to read all the posts. What about a sorcerer that is truly different than a wizard. By using Sorcerer Points (spell point system), you place the sorcerer into a unique class - as I suggest it should be. The narrative might go...

It's a game, not moral philosophy I'm all for philosophy, I have a degree in it. But this is a game. The alignment mechanics is a simplified system to provide some parameters or restrictions to a character. You can't one day risk your life with no reward to save the village, and the next...

No alignment. Which is to say, let the alignment grow organically out of the character's personality (who they are before stats, die rolls, etc.). This will allow for a character with a main theme and nuanced variations. More like you and I. In short, more improv, role-playing, and storytelling.

Puppeteers versus roleplayers Great way to put it. An extension of the player like a puppet in their hand that has no character (inner life) whatsoever. If you won't role-play (pretend to be someone else), why are you playing an RPG? Go play Chess or Bridge.

This is nothing more than the continuing battle over who speaks for Gary Gygax, his sons (Ernie & Luke) who were with him during the beginnings of D&D, or the "next generation." If you want to support Gary Gxgax's legacy, you can find it to a degree in "Castles & Crusades." Or, in what Ernie...

This idea of a visual reference leading to an out of scale head or whatever is silly. Don't make them look cartoonish. Find some other visually creative way to make the distinction, assuming that is even necessary. For halflings: feet, hair, etc. For gnomes: ears, facial features. Or include...

This idea of a visual reference leading to an out of scale head or whatever is silly. Don't make them look cartoonish. Find some other visually creative way to make the distinction, assuming that is even necessary. For halflings: feet, hair, etc. For gnomes: ears, facial features. Or include...

DMMike: "I'm also expecting Pathfinder 2 to have better CR flow...so you might want to keep your eye on that." I have been following some of Pathfinder 2 combat examples, and I am impressed with what I have seen so far. It looks very promising, at least relative to what I am trying to do.

My Thanks to Thondor & DMMike. Very interesting and useful information. These are some of the ideas I am using to wrap my head around what I want to ultimately create on the game table. The simple answer is to have more "realism," at least from a tactical perspective, while still maintaining...

This idea is most interesting. My immediate thought that sprang from this would be to add a "movement opportunity" as long as the character didn't use all of their movement during their initiative turn. This might be a simpler (mechanically) way to minimize the "standing around" effect, at least...

Standard array or point buy from the book. Player choice. But I really like the "Advantage/Disadvantage" system, and the 2d4 +7. I will add these as player choice.

Blue, thank you for taking the time to lay this out. Very informative. It is quite lovely to have a place such as this to throw out an idea and have others respond offering solid support. With the above advice, I am going to try a segmented Combat Round, call it 3 (4?) mini CR's within the...

"How dare you sir, how dare you!" suggesting that Sir Lancelot was a mythical figure. He was real, and could not be defeated, except by love.

Mercer et al are polished performers. They have a large amount of theatre training and experience, plus a performers mindset that brings the show to life. And of course an exiting fan base due to their work in the gaming industry. It is in some ways a throwback to early radio shows. In some...

Products succeed or fail for many reasons. Some you can plan for, others not. One difference for 5th was more money behind the product. That is huge. Two companies with similar products: A & B. B is the better product, but A has much more money for marketing, distribution, development, etc. A...

Thanks much Dave2008, I will take a look at your suggestions.

Shiroiken, thank you for the response. I can see how "my" idea might end up being far more complicated and time consuming than the benefits gained. I can see where your second idea could bog the game down with players taking quite a bit of time to write down, trying to cover multiple...

While I have an original copy, played out "lo these many years ago," and don't have a need to purchase another version, a recopy is not a bad idea. It can still make for a good starting point for those new to GM'ing/world creating. And for you "youngsters" out there, it can be interesting and...

Thanks for the clarification. I thought it would play out that way, though I wasn't sure. And I suppose, this like almost everything else can be modified if so desired. I also like your frontliner tactics.

Thanks for this discussion. I think it shows some of the problems with a set of rules that perhaps tries to walk a fine middle line of "it's ultimately up to you" and here are the stated rules for those who need/want it spelled out. Not that I'm complaining mind you. I find these rules to work...