glass said:
It's funny how some song seem to lend themselves to being covered.
That's when you know a song is a "standard".
glass said:
They definitely wrote it, and they did record it, but apparently after Nilsson did. Interesting question -does that make his version a cover? Or theirs?
Theirs. Same as Michael Bolton's "How Am I Supposed To Live Without You" or Keith Whitley's "I Never Go Around Mirrors". In all three cases, they wrote it, but they let someone else
record it
first, so now theirs is a cover. (Of course, one might argue that they performed it during writing, possibly even recorded a demo. But that's nitpicking beyond the standard usage of "cover" or common sense.

)
This also, apparently, applies to Prince's "Nothing Compares 2 U", but not in the way I previously thought. Even though he wrote it, his AND Sinead's version are both covers, since he wrote it for a group he was trying to help get started back in 1985 called The Family, and they recorded it and released it first.
glass said:
Are any of those the version from the Charmed opening credits? If not, anyone know who did do that one?
Love Spit Love. It was originally done for the soundtrack of the movie "The Craft" and then used as the theme for Charmed.
Personally, my favorite is the Snake River Conspiracy version. It is admittedly an acquired taste as it is very .... different. But that's in keeping with the theme of the song, no?
