marimbaguy715
Explorer
I haven't read the whole thread so forgive me if this was mentioned elsewhere, but putting Phandelver on this list is an odd choice given the book isn't out yet. Or are we judging it on the Lost Mine portion?
Murder in Baldur's Gate 9
Storm King's Thunder 20
Tomb of Annihilation 27
Waterdeep: Dragon Heist 9
Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage 25
The Wild Beyond the Witchlight 24
Phandelver and Below: The Shattered Obelisk 18
Tales from the Yawning Portal 46
Ghosts of Saltmarsh 47
Keys From the Golden Vault 13
Light of Xaryxis 28
Yawning Portal is overrated. One or two of the dungeons are good, but many of them are slogs, poorly designed, or pointless. The Tomb of Horrors is especially bad (and I know, the point of it is to be incredibly deadly even for high level characters, but that doesn't make it good or fun). And the book also suffers from a common early 5e adventure issue where it buries important information in the description of a dungeon room rather than provide the DM with the most relevant information up front.
Murder in Baldur's Gate 9
Storm King's Thunder 20
Tomb of Annihilation 27
Waterdeep: Dragon Heist 9
Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage 25
The Wild Beyond the Witchlight 24
Phandelver and Below: The Shattered Obelisk 18
Tales from the Yawning Portal 46
Ghosts of Saltmarsh 47
Keys From the Golden Vault 13
Light of Xaryxis 28
Yawning Portal is overrated. One or two of the dungeons are good, but many of them are slogs, poorly designed, or pointless. The Tomb of Horrors is especially bad (and I know, the point of it is to be incredibly deadly even for high level characters, but that doesn't make it good or fun). And the book also suffers from a common early 5e adventure issue where it buries important information in the description of a dungeon room rather than provide the DM with the most relevant information up front.
