Pielorinho said:Olive, I just finished Iron Council. My thoughts, without giving too much away:
-Of the three Crobuzon books, this one is far and away the most political. That's something that I enjoy a lot, but other folks may not like so much; be aware when you read it that you're going to be reading, not a didactic work, but a work that offers a grim and thoughtful treatment of social upheaval in a fantasy world.
-Perdido Street Station made me gasp on just about every other page with some bizarre new idea. This one didn't quite do that, but it still had a fair share of breathtaking scenes.
-I think the characters are better drawn in this one than in his previous books, and the language is the same surefooted baroquery that you'll either love or you'll hate. Obviously it works well for me.
Pielorinho said:Funny, I was just thinking of picking up some Gene Wolfe based on Mieville's recommendation. Synchrofreakinnicity, don'tcha know.
He does seem to occasionally wander off in weirdness that serves no purpose whatsoever. The entire handlinger sequence in Perdido Street was just to show off "hey, look, here's a really weird, grotesque element of my aw3some 53tting, d00ds" kinda moment. It didn't further the storytelling at all; in fact, it interrupted the momentum of the story for no apparent reason. Which was unfortunate, as it took at least 200 pages to build up any momentum to begin with.Pielorinho said:I don't find it weird for the sake of weirdness, any more than Conan is violent for the sake of violence. The weirdness really adds to the storytelling for me.