To be honest, I had thought the numbers would be different this time around. I argued that there were a number of posters, back in the original poll, that like me were in the middle of a 3e (or whatever) campaign and would likely switch over when that ended and the whole "splitting the fanbase" thing wasn't as large as it appeared.
Well, it appears that I was wrong. The split is very much there. A real shame I suppose. Although it does speak a lot to the strength of the 3e ruleset I suppose.
In any case, I'm more than big enough (hey, stop with the fat jokes, I'm sensitive) to admit when I'm mistaken.
Oddly enough, even though I'm in the "no 4Ed for me, thank you very much" camp, I agree with you about the way this poll is shaping up. This really doesn't look like what happened in the 2Ed=>3Ed changeover.
I hoped 3.5 would continue to be a strong market force, but I expected- as WotC probably did- to see a slow changeover to 4Ed, with 3.5 lovers like me accounting for 25-33% of the "D&D nation."
This 55+% "anti-4Ed" result to me does seem to speak volumes about the strength of the 3.X system...as well as the effect that 3PP had upon the gaming market.
Still, only time will tell if the numbers for installed customer base will translate into lagging sales for the new product, since it is really designed to bring new blood into the hobby and/or brand. (And maybe "drain the swamp" of 3PPs, as some have alleged.)
Last edited: