Nephtys said:
I simply assumed that just like Thef'chu Nefut with the Domain of the Dead was unable to take the followers of other deities to her afterlife so would Bea'ral be unable to affect the divine magic of other deities. If Llama decides otherwise I can only congratulate you, because all other deities are then almost completely powerless.
You'll notice that Voidrazors followers resisted all the effects of your action, for both arcane and divine magic as well as their own spell like and supernatural abilities. And I doubt that the other deities will simply accept your power over their followers without discussion. After all, the elves and elementals are as dependant upon magic as the goblins if not more so.
So we should not contradict one another IC? We should just go along with any action any of us decide no matter how outrageous when it directly concerns our own followers. So if I was to write that one of the fragments of the moon was to fall to earth and just happen to crush the Elven city and everyone in it you'd all be ok with that? You'd all simply continue the story from that point?
-
My point about the Goblins is that even if you could shut down both arcane and divine magic for 100 years the politically dominant priesthood would still be in charge of things locally, and since the priests can still communicate with their deity trough prayer they will still know her will. They know that when they die they will still belong to her, so they wouldn't disobey her.
Just think of how powerful the idea of God is in the real world, where the existence of the divine is unproven. And then consider how faithful people who have been living in a theocratic society for a thousand years in direct contact with their deity would be, when they know she will show no mercy for any failure to obey her will. Consider how obedient those little sheep would be, when in the real world people blow themselves up for far less.
I am not saying that you can not have legitimate concerns about the actions of another god and whether they should be able to do something or not. My point is that direct contradiction should be brought up here rather than the IC post. If you do not it will only lead to a continual I say it goes this way and you say it goes that, which is only a glorified uh uh, uh huh "argument".
As far as Bea'ral's supposed ability to make other gods powerless, well, lets just say I don't exactly find the argument valid coming from someone who just threw the moon into the sun. His actions didn't effect the gods ability to do anything at all, just their followers.
I don't see where the Dweller's followers resisted the disruption. The only thing I could find was the greater than intended effect and their fleeing underground to survive the moon and eating particular minereals to survive the disruption.
As far as the goblin empire, first, if Thef'chu Nefut is willing to devote that much effort to keeping an empire together, then you are correct. My assumption though is she would be unwilling to coordinate grain shipments or tally tax records or one of thousands of other tasks she would be forced to communicate. There is a great deal of tedium in running an empire, particularly in a pre-industrial civilization.
Countries have worshipped the same god for thousands of years and have perpetually gone to war with each other. A unified religion, even one which does not want war, tend to go to war because that is human nature. Goblinoid nature is even worse.
And for reference, yes, if you decided that Thef'chu Nefut destroyed the moon and sent it crashing down on the elven city, Bea'ral wouldn't even resist it. But that is Bea'ral. Others I assume would have something to say about it, but if they did it correctly (from my point of view) they would wisk their followers away to a safe place or recreate an exact duplicate of the city, resurrecting their followers or if they really couldn't stand what you had done, and could only see their diety directly stopping Thef'chu Nefut actions, then bringing it here and posting something like:
I can't see Bea'ral allowing the destruction of all his followers. He would directly resist the action. Suicidal_Llama could you resolve this conflict.
Another way, without resorting to deliberation would be to put something like: Thef'chu Nefut sees the goblin empire begin to crumble and exerts her aspect of fate to write into destiny that the Goblin Empire would stand for all time.
Of course doing that may cause others to say, hey wait a minute can she do that? But again the is suicidal Llama's job, not mine.