Invisibility to animals. Is it too good?

[Tom McCafferty]

What should happen when a character with invisibility and invisibility to animals attacks a non-animal creature?

Do they become visible but remain invisible to animals, or do they become visible to all creatures?

 

[hong]

Invisibility to animals goes poof as soon as you attack anyone, just the same as regular invisibility.

 

[Relentless]

Indeed.

 

[Pielorinho]

What should happen when a character with invisibility and invisibility to animals attacks a non-animal creature?

Do they become visible but remain invisible to animals, or do they become visible to all creatures?

Not only that, but

If a warded character touches an animal or attacks any creature, even with a spell, the spell ends for all recipients.

In our adventuring career with a ninth-level druid, we've had occasion to use this spell exactly once. It's not a particularly overpowered spell in most campaigns, I think.

Daniel

 

[Darklone]

Right. My druid prepared it exactly once and tried to use it... then the DM had suddenly decided that THESE animals had Int 6.

 

[Henry]

Basically, the spells' effects are judged separately - so a condition that would end either one, would end both at the same time.