marshmandr
Villager
Can either true polymorph or polymorph turn an incorporeal creature or spirit into a physical being?
-
The VOIDRUNNER'S CODEX is LIVE! Explore new worlds, fight oppressive empires, fend off fearsome aliens, and wield deadly psionics with this comprehensive boxed set expansion for 5E and A5E!
Polymorph and spirits/incorporeal creatures
- Thread starter marshmandr
- Start date
Warmaster Horus
Explorer
Not sure why not, unless they are a shapechanger.
Depends on the creature.
Unlike 3E, in 5E there is no general rule on incorporealness -- each creature with an incorporeal-like ability has its own rules for how that functions. In most cases, it's simply reflected in the creatures damage resistances and immunities, and not called out as a unique ability, though most creatures that a 3E-era gamer would consider 'incorporeal undead' do have an Incorporeal Movement ability that allows them to pass through solid objects.
So for example, a ghost that is currently using its Etherealness ability can't be polymorphed by a caster that isn't also on the Ethereal plane. A specter, though, doesn't have that ability, so would be vulnerable.
Note, however, that when a polymorphed creature is reduced to 0 hit points, it reverts to its normal form, so polymorphing a spectre wouldn't let you kill the spectre without dealing with its damage resistance unless you use an effect that kills the polymorphed spectre without reducing it to 0 hit points.
--
Pauper
Unlike 3E, in 5E there is no general rule on incorporealness -- each creature with an incorporeal-like ability has its own rules for how that functions. In most cases, it's simply reflected in the creatures damage resistances and immunities, and not called out as a unique ability, though most creatures that a 3E-era gamer would consider 'incorporeal undead' do have an Incorporeal Movement ability that allows them to pass through solid objects.
So for example, a ghost that is currently using its Etherealness ability can't be polymorphed by a caster that isn't also on the Ethereal plane. A specter, though, doesn't have that ability, so would be vulnerable.
Note, however, that when a polymorphed creature is reduced to 0 hit points, it reverts to its normal form, so polymorphing a spectre wouldn't let you kill the spectre without dealing with its damage resistance unless you use an effect that kills the polymorphed spectre without reducing it to 0 hit points.
--
Pauper
Wouldn't it by it's very un-nature be an undead mouse?
Baron Opal II
Hero
Not with true polymorph, I believe.
Similar Threads
D&D General
Simulacrum and then True Polymorph
