D&D 5E Survivor Campaign Settings II: Blackmoor Wins!

[FormerlyHemlock]

Birthright 21
Blackmoor 20
Council of Wyrms 20
Dark Sun 19
Dragon Fist 16
Dragonlance 20
Eberron 20

Forgotten Realms 19 - so many godlike NPCs there is no room for PCs

Ghostwalk 20
Greyhawk 20
Jakandor 20
Kingdoms of Kalamar 20
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 18
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 20
Pelinore 20
Planescape 21
Ravenloft 20

Spelljammer 19 - creatively Aristotelian/Platonic physics/cosmology, villainous elves, vast conspiracies, fleets of beholders, monsters with tens of thousands of HP: what's not to love? Originated much of the anti-hack-n-slash cosmopolitanism which eventually led to Planescape. Tied with Darksun for TSR's most innovative setting.

Thunder Rift 20
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 20

 

[lowkey13]

*Deleted by user*

 

[FormerlyHemlock]

It's City State of the Invincible Overlord (which became a campaign setting in 3e) - Judge's Guild.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_State_of_the_Invincible_Overlord

Okay, then in that case I changed my downvote to FR.

 

[Gradine]

Birthright 19 Never again
Blackmoor 20
Council of Wyrms 20
Dark Sun 19
Dragon Fist 16
Dragonlance 20
Eberron 21
Forgotten Realms 19
Ghostwalk 20
Greyhawk 20
Jakandor 20
Kingdoms of Kalamar 20
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 18
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 20
Pelinore 20
Planescape 21
Ravenloft 20
Spelljammer 19
Thunder Rift 20
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 20

 

[Tony Vargas]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 21 - Though the first book called Blackmoor wasn't a setting, one was eventually published, and Dave deserves to win one of these things...
Council of Wyrms 20
Dark Sun 19
Dragon Fist 16
Dragonlance 20
Eberron 21
Forgotten Realms 19
Ghostwalk 20
Greyhawk 20
Jakandor 20
Kingdoms of Kalamar 20
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 18
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 18 - Disqualified. I'm sorry, you must be an actually setting to play, not a glorified neighborhood. Do you see Cormyr on here? Sharn? The Flaneas? No, they're bits of settings.
Pelinore 20
Planescape 21
Ravenloft 20
Spelljammer 19
Thunder Rift 20
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 20

 

[Ahrimon]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 21
Council of Wyrms 18
Dark Sun 19
Dragon Fist 16
Dragonlance 20
Eberron 21
Forgotten Realms 19
Ghostwalk 20
Greyhawk 20
Jakandor 20
Kingdoms of Kalamar 20
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 18
Mystara 20
Points of Light (Nentir Vale) 18
Pelinore 20
Planescape 21
Ravenloft 20
Spelljammer 20
Thunder Rift 20
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 20

 

[Twiggly the Gnome]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 21
Council of Wyrms 18
Dark Sun 19
Dragon Fist 16
Dragonlance 20
Eberron 22
Forgotten Realms 17
Ghostwalk 20
Greyhawk 20
Jakandor 20
Kingdoms of Kalamar 20
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 18
Mystara 20
Points of Light (Nentir Vale) 18
Pelinore 20
Planescape 21
Ravenloft 20
Spelljammer 20
Thunder Rift 20
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 20

 

[Jacob Marley]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 21
Council of Wyrms 18
Dark Sun 19
Dragon Fist 16
Dragonlance 20
Eberron 22
Forgotten Realms 15 If your favorite setting is anything else but the Realms, kill the Realms now! We don't want another Mordenkainen situation here.
Ghostwalk 20
Greyhawk 21
Jakandor 20
Kingdoms of Kalamar 20
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 18
Mystara 20
Points of Light (Nentir Vale) 18
Pelinore 20
Planescape 21
Ravenloft 20
Spelljammer 20
Thunder Rift 20
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 20

 

[Calminor]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 21
Council of Wyrms 18
Dark Sun 19 +1 = 20 barbarian halflings before they were cool
Dragon Fist 16
Dragonlance 20
Eberron 22
Forgotten Realms 15 -2 = 13 It's too... plain
Ghostwalk 20
Greyhawk 21
Jakandor 20
Kingdoms of Kalamar 20
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 18
Mystara 20
Points of Light (Nentir Vale) 18
Pelinore 20
Planescape 21
Ravenloft 20
Spelljammer 20
Thunder Rift 20
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 20

 

[mflayermonk]

Birthright 19
Blackmoor 21
Council of Wyrms 18
Dark Sun 20
Dragon Fist 16
Dragonlance 18
Eberron 22
Forgotten Realms 13
Ghostwalk 20
Greyhawk 21
Jakandor 21 I've got a bunch of these books and I hope Jakandor winning will raise the value so I can sell them on ebay.
Kingdoms of Kalamar 20
Lankhmar 21
Mahasarpa 18
Mystara 20
Points of Light (Nentir Vale) 18
Pelinore 20
Planescape 21
Ravenloft 20
Spelljammer 20
Thunder Rift 20
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 20