Hamburger Mary
Explorer
So what's the verdict? By the straight score it's 319 to 316 in favor of Pathfinder... but going by registered voters it's 161 to 136 in favor of Eberron.TerraDave said:
The Best & Worst of 3rd Edition: Ultimate 3E: Unearthed Arcana, Eberron, Pathfinder
TerraDave
5ever, or until 2024
Eberron, based on the votes of logged in members, is the Ultimate Product of 3E.
Logged in members voted as follows:
Eberron: 159
Pathfinder: 134
Unearthed Arcana: 92
Among total voters, Pathfinder led with 319 to 316 for Eberron (UA got 140). However, as noted in the first post of the thread, this was a public poll, and that could be used to determine the winner. Given Eberron clear advantage in logged in members, I am comfortable in declaring it the winner!
Congratulations to all the winning products. And thanks to everyone who voted.
Logged in members voted as follows:
Eberron: 159
Pathfinder: 134
Unearthed Arcana: 92
Among total voters, Pathfinder led with 319 to 316 for Eberron (UA got 140). However, as noted in the first post of the thread, this was a public poll, and that could be used to determine the winner. Given Eberron clear advantage in logged in members, I am comfortable in declaring it the winner!
Congratulations to all the winning products. And thanks to everyone who voted.
Kristian Serrano
Explorer
You don't have to tell us what we already knew. 
Just teasing. Honestly, I see this more as a survey rather than a competition. It's not like anyone wins a prize for this; it's just good fun to participate.
Just teasing. Honestly, I see this more as a survey rather than a competition. It's not like anyone wins a prize for this; it's just good fun to participate.
WhatGravitas
Explorer
Erik Mona said:In the spirit of the 2000 election, I take solace in the triumph of the popular vote.
--Erik
But still, both are very good. And while I voted Eberron, I still find it surprising, how much followers Pathfinder got within what? The last year? That's definitively a feat!
Cheers, LT.
TerraDave
5ever, or until 2024
Mr. Mona: Pathfinder certainly has a devoted following. Congragulations also for Fiendish Codex I: Hordes of the Abyss and employing James Jacobs, one of only two designers to have 3 wining or finalist products.
SavageRobby
First Post
Lord Tirian said:
But still, both are very good. And while I voted Eberron, I still find it surprising, how much followers Pathfinder got within what? The last year? That's definitively a feat!
Cheers, LT.
I don't really find it surprising. The product itself is top notch. I mean, really really good. (I'm going to run it - in another game system, its that good.)
But also I think Paizo the company has won fans beyond their products, similar to Saturn (the car company). That is, it helps that they have a good product, but they've also marketed their company well, focusing on the people, being accessible, trying to innovate without being too strange, etc - and I think that has resonated with a lot of folks (I know it has with me), especially considering the events of the last year and they way they handled themselves.
