Raven Crowking
First Post
I liked your car analogy better.
Not surprising.
However, both analogies are equally valid.
The REH pastiche analogy simply makes the absurdity of claiming that the two are the same thing a little more obvious, for those who are not used to using a more subtle standard of measurement.
Not that recognizing the differences between a Model T and a Corvette ought to require anything approaching a subtle standard of measurement.
Nor should recognizing the difference between the "larger than life" qualities of TSR-D&D and 4e.
RC