iserith
Magic Wordsmith
A question for those who feel that intimidation is removing agency: What does it mean to be proficient in Intimidation? What is the purpose of the game mechanic? Why would a player choose it for their character?
To be clear, the skill Intimidation doesn't remove agency - the DM can, however, depending on his or her approach to adjudication.
The reason a player might choose this skill for his or her character is to have a bonus to ability checks called for by the DM when the player's stated goal of influencing someone via the approach of overt threats, hostile actions, and physical violence has an uncertain outcome. If this is a goal and approach the player intend to use frequently, having a bonus to the ability check will probably benefit that player. Some players might also choose it because it represents some defining aspect of the character.