DND_Reborn
The High Aldwin
But the lower roll does not ignore it. So it is still satisfied. You can argue it either way and be correct.This ignores the higher roll as "a d20 roll of 10 or lower."
I agree it is completely up to the DM, but even the most generous interpretation is what is followed by many of the people replying to this thread and mine from a couple weeks ago. Many responses in my thread felt I was nerfing rogues if I didn't rule it in the most generous manner.So it's up to the GM to decide to take the Middle Road or Least Generous, because the Most Generous ruling doesn't respect RAI.
IMO you can justifiably rule it any of those three ways, and there are probably others I haven't thought of.