Adventure Path starting with Sunless Citadel - Have you tried to run the whole thing?

[Zad]

We started to but gave up. Sunless was nice, Forge of fury was nice. Speaker in Dreams was just silly (our DM thought).

Heart of Nightfang spire was a travesty of a module and I warn people off it any chance I get.

At that point we pretty much got off the adventure path.

 

[Wulf Ratbane]

Isn't that the one with the demon that's WAY powerful for that level of the party, that does nothing but fly away laughing?

No, no, he died like a little bitch.

Same goes for the SECOND one he summoned in.

Oh yeah... I have no plans to ever write up Bastion of Broken Souls. That was my least favorite of the adventure path-- in no way the fault of the module, it was just anti-climactic: the end of the campaign and the end of my time with that gaming group, as I moved away.

I don't have any warm fuzzies for Bastion...


Wulf

 

[Dinkeldog]

Speaker in Dreams is still my favorite of the series, Standing Stone is still my least favorite.

I would only run through the whole series again if I had a group of players I didn't know or a group that had several inexperienced players. I'd also go through and tweak more of the monsters--access to classbooks made the PCs much more powerful than the Core-limited NPCs. I did several of them before. I think I would do even more now.

 

[JacktheRabbit]

Speaker in Dreams is still my favorite of the series, Standing Stone is still my least favorite.

I would only run through the whole series again if I had a group of players I didn't know or a group that had several inexperienced players. I'd also go through and tweak more of the monsters--access to classbooks made the PCs much more powerful than the Core-limited NPCs. I did several of them before. I think I would do even more now.

If the PC's seem too powerful then just sneak some Tuskan Raiders into the modules.

How is the group doing with Ben gone?