If you believe in the scale of physics and the universe, its completely illogical to pick option 1.
The best way a physicist once put it. The universe is so insanely incredibly vast, that its actually a nigh probabilistic certainty that at some other point in the universe at some point in time a creature that is chemically exactly you will live your exact same life. THAT's how much stuff is out there.
Now other intelligent life on earth, or in the galaxy right now.... ok maybe maybe not. But in the entirety of the universe....100%.
The best way a physicist once put it. The universe is so insanely incredibly vast, that its actually a nigh probabilistic certainty that at some other point in the universe at some point in time a creature that is chemically exactly you will live your exact same life. THAT's how much stuff is out there.
Now other intelligent life on earth, or in the galaxy right now.... ok maybe maybe not. But in the entirety of the universe....100%.