Ok. Antibiotics have done their thing. Taxes done (don't owe. woohoo! But with my dad dying last year, there was all kindsa extra forms/paperwork I've never had to deal with before. Not gettin' anything back. But don't owe. Which is more important...to me.) ANYwho...on to the judgements.
Round II: Match 1
phoamslinger's
The Favor
vs.
PirateCat's Repo
Seal
vs.
UselessTriviaMan's
Royal Pains
1) Writing Style/Skill: Who's brilliant idea was it to have to judge 3 of you at the same time?! Ugh. Ok, we have here three great tales. Three adept writers. Three stories with great plots, solid character development, descriptive text and a multitude of evocative settings...and a couple of typos (thanks phoamslinger
that really don't impact the skill or style points all that much...if at all.
I'll get into more of all of this under the "Enjoyment" section. But for strict Skill and Style, each does their job admirably and notably well. No edges here. This is a 3 horse race for sure!
2) Picture Use:
Favor's use of the images are all fairly straight forward. I very much enjoyed the magical everburning chandelier/candelabra in the temple. Made a ton of sense and evocative as a "temple of the sun god" ornament.
Repo's image of a Vegas "chapel" and the incorporating of the figure behind it as the "nun/call girl" uses it a bit more thoroughly.
But then
Royal Pains comes in with the elaborate candelabra that the main character actually interacts with versus just sees, use of the figure behind as Vashka (in a funny headdress the magess doesn't quite know why she's wearing) AND the bouquets of white lilies, which admittedly I really didn't notice until reading your story, as an essential element of plot. Wow. Way to use an image's details, UselessTriviaMan.
The seal. [everybody say "Awwww"] The seal on the rock.
Favor's use as one of the pivotal elements for the "Dei Ehm" (which I LOVED, but more on that later) plot device was not at all what I was expecting and enjoyed since I thought, at first, it was simple window dressing. Nicely done. I will admit being comPLETEly horrified at themention of the PC with the seal hat! lol. But, it is totally in keeping with what/how PCs will do things...and I can think of several players I've known over the years who would have done the extact same thing. hahaha. Very funny and a nice add.
In
Repo Seal, obviously, the seal is a major element if not actual character, per se. But integral to the story and again, went from being "Ok, so they have a seal with them" in the beginning to fleshing out the how and why it is there was beautifully done. Perhaps, more importantly, it gives us a nice facet to the main characters (who, admittedly, up to that point are not the most likeable individuals) and makes them sympathetic. Again, wonderfully done.
In
Royal Pains, the seal is an actual character. Humorous. Independent despite being a "familiar" as we understand it in D&D. Very nicely done and, again, integral to the plot and with a hand in the resolution.
I do think, however, the beautifully woven crafting of the animal in
Repo Seal and what it does for the story as a whole does go to PirateCat for this pic.
The desert, as my esteemed fellow judge mentions, it's a desert. It's a set piece and used nicely as such by all three. While the desert is a bit more important, fleshed out and interesting as a setting in
Royal Pains, I don't really see an advantage here. It was a desert. There ya go.
The rock head of
Favor was exactly as I expected, the earth elemental creature that the Players/PCs searched for. Having read your expanded explanation of it being a galeb duhr...I really didn't get that from the story. Just that it was the elemental creature...and that's fine. It did what it had to do.
The use as an indian artifact in
Repo was well done. Simple and furthering, if not initiating, the plot. The way you take each image and really make it count, not just as an image, but as intrinsic to character motivations is very much admired.
Royal Pains' petrifying venom was where I was thinking it was going. You had statues all over the desert and I thought, at first, that the head was just some throw away nod toward that. Come to find, while it is a petrified person from the deadly-halfling desert, but is actually the source or, well, the focus, of the princess' madness. Again, caught me off guard and pleasantly surprised me as more than I expected it to be.
I think in the case of the stone head, again, we have a 3-way happening.
Grr. SOMEbody's gotta get an edge around here someplace.
3) Personal Enjoyment:
The Favor was, for me, the most entertaining read. The recurring humor. The tropes. The "zapping green ball of light" known in the ancient tongue as the Dei Ehm. The PC/player interactions that I could "hear" occurring at any number of my tables. Very funny, a bit nostalgic and highly entertaining.
Repo Seal is a brilliantly told brilliant tale. While I'm not big on the "modern" genre, the detail, darker interactions/humor and characters, and creativity in general cannot be denied. We have stealth and intrigue, pacing, action...even a touch of horror (he's gonna EAT the cutesy wootsy seal?! NOOOO!) It is a great read without a shred of "magic" or "fantasy" to be found. I could see this as a great game/scenario/adventure in whatever modern genre game system you like.
Royal Pains started out, for me, kinda "eh." But very quickly became "oo!" The character development was solid. The setting sparked all kinds of things for me to use in an adventure. From the gatorbear to the petrifying venom and "primitive halfling tribe" who ride "ostretches" with the sacred/spiritual connection to their ancestors...lots of great ideas here. Throw in some dark insanity and a few flavorful snapshots of "life in the castle." I enjoyed this, ultimately, as much as
The Favor for a [non-spoofy] fantasy story.
Final Decision: I read all of these twice over...and didn't mind one moment of reading any of them. These are wonderful tales that might each be an exemplar for their type. When I boil everything down to a gooey thick paste of flavor and fun, I am left with only the most marginal of "leads." This 3 horse race ends in a photo finish, quite literally.
Steel Dragons' pick for Round II: Match 1 goes to
UselessTriviaMan's Royal Pains.