Half-celestial

[Navar]

What is the ECL for a Half-Celestial? According to Book of Exalted Deeds it is +2, but according to the Monster Manual it is +4, what is the correct value?

 

[AGGEMAM]

What is the ECL for a Half-Celestial? According to Book of Exalted Deeds it is +2, but according to the Monster Manual it is +4, what is the correct value?

The MMs +4.

 

[Korak]

What is the ECL for a Half-Celestial? According to Book of Exalted Deeds it is +2, but according to the Monster Manual it is +4, what is the correct value?

BoED has an alternate scheme for the Half-Celestial template to facilitate its use for PCs. That scheme starts at +2 ECL and scales up as the PC levels to reflect the power of template rising with HD(class levels).

 

[nameless]

It's still not entirely settled whether or not hit dice from class levels count for the Half-Celestial abilities. Most templates don't care what class levels you have, but Half-Celestial and Half-Fiend have text that ambiguously might supercede that rule.

The MM's +4 is definitely adequate for the template with all the spell-like abilities, but is the BoED's +2 fine without them, and would the LA change as more class levels are gained?