Jesus Christ, would you stop being so condescending towards other people who use these forums? This is an incredibly rude way to talk to someone.
i am sorry you find it so upsetting but to me the post i responded to started with emotion, listed a specific case, then finally got around to an example of a very different topic - one which was covered in the first post on this thread in fact.
See, telling them that to me their statement initially and their provided example were of two different things thrown together etc and then illusrating how far apart they seem to me and even finishing up with that if it makes sense to them thats fine... i thought that was Ok around here where we can disagree, point out our disagreements, even highlight where we do agree and then make allowances for the fact that if others see it differently that is fine too.
i really do not have to understand someone else's reasoning to say that its fine if it makes sense to them, do I?
Like i said during the majority of my post (included in the parts you choose to cut out odd thing that), it seemed there was much agreement between their example of play and mine as well - agreed, much more than disagree.