Pirates of the Caribbean 4 - Coming in 2011

[Desdichado]

After seeing the excellent job Terry Gilliam did with Baron Munchausen, I'd see that one in a heartbeat...

After seeing the terrible job Terry Gilliam did with The Brothers Grimm, I'd skip that one in a heartbeat...

 

[Megaton]

I'm not sure about Gilliam but I've always found these movies really entertaining. I guess after the box office take that the trilogy had, we should have seen a third on coming.

 

[The Grumpy Celt]

I don't think Mad Hatter would require much acting on Depp's part. Just stick a hat on him...

 

[Ranger REG]

I'm fine with this--as long as it doesn't involve Will Turner or Elizabeth (Swan) Turner.

There's plenty more that can be done with Jack Sparrow and Barbossa, but the tale of the Turners is done, thanks.

Don't hold your breath. We may see The Flying Dutchman again.

Yet I agree, that story pretty much ended albeit badly.

 

[Relique du Madde]

Talking about plot holes and stupidity in the 3rd movie...

The The Flying Dutchman stipulation wasn't that much of a stipulation.

So what if you can't step on dry land every 10 years (note the movie said 'dry land' and not 'the lands of the living' which would have been a BIG difference in the stipulation), that doesn't stop a good pirate king from building a Pirate city that is built entirely on a series of piers in a shallow lagoon. That also doesn't stop you from going to port and having wenches and booze brought to your ship. Sure you have to ferry the souls of those who died at sea to the lands of the death, but honestly I don't see that as being a full time job even back in the 17th/18th centuries.

 

[Cat Moon]

Sure, the third one was just a little too long for my taste and a bit droll in the middle. It did however, close off the storyline quite well. Unless Disney is going for a new trilogy based on Turner's son, I just don't see this as worthwhile prospect.

 

[Ranger REG]

Sure, the third one was just a little too long for my taste and a bit droll in the middle. It did however, close off the storyline quite well. Unless Disney is going for a new trilogy based on Turner's son, I just don't see this as worthwhile prospect.

Forget about the Turners. I just like to see more [mis]adventures of Captain Jack Sparrow.

 

[Oni]

First one great, second one meh, third one I left the theatre a little angry they had managed to take something that had started out really cool and make it into an utter pile of crap.

They should just stop making these.

 

[Ranger REG]

First one great, second one meh, third one I left the theatre a little angry they had managed to take something that had started out really cool and make it into an utter pile of crap.

They should just stop making these.

Because the third film is crap? Nah.

 

[megamania]

I never even finshed watching #3. A #4.... for the money only I guess. Doubt I'll see it unless the kids twict my arm or there really is nothing to watch for several months before and after.