Problem Domains that need Fixing

[Emiricol]

An updated problem list is below. Someone tell me what to change in the guide

PROBLEM LIST

Beastmaster Domain Spells
1. Animal Friendship DELETED
RESOLVED

Charm Domain Spells
RESOLVED

Hatred Domain Spells
RESOLVED

Moon Domain Spells
RESOLVED

================================================
NOT RESOLVED

The following spells need to be replaced:

FRCS
Cavern - Aethaddyn, Uluk
Charm - Bajaer, Belarna
Darkness - Aethaddyn, Kirok

3. Blacklight
4. Armor of Darkness
5. Darkbolt
​

Elf - Targan Lithmoor
Fate - Felicitas, Prosimus
Halfling - Felicitas
Hatred - Parushan
Metal - Kovar
Moon - Lunakav

2. Moonbeam
3. Moon Blade
5. Moon Path
9. Moonfire
​

Nobility - Aohalim, Os, Targan Lithmoor
Orc - Uluk
Renewal - Murryghn
Rune - Os
Scalykind (We call it "Saurian Domain") - Naeron
Slime - Aethaddyn
Spider - Shadoth

6. Spider Curse
7. Stone Spiders
9. Spider Shapes
​

Storm - Eraekoth, Kirok, Typhus
Suffering - Caelon, Parushan
Time - Alyhndro
Tyranny - Beher
Undeath - Murryghn

* Contain spells detailed in the FRCS




Deities and Demigods
Artifice - Kovar

7. Hardening
8. True Creation
​

Community - Suerl
Creation - Kovar

8. True Creation
9. Genesis
​

Darkness (See FRCS)
Glory - Alyhndro

6. Bolt of Glory
8. Crown of Glory
​

Liberation - Belarna

6. Greater Dispelling
9. Unbinding
​

Madness - Lunakav

2. Touch of Madness
5. Bolts of Bedevilment
8. Maddening Scream
​

Nobility (See FRCS)
Scalykind (See FRCS)
Weather - Talina

* Contain spells detailed in the Deities & Demigods (D&D) book


Defenders of the Faith
Beastmaster - Murrhygn

2. Beastmask
5. Bear's Heart
​

Celerity - Alyhndro
Community (See D&D)
Creation (See D&D)
Glory (See D&D)
Madness (See D&D)

 

[Emiricol]

Ok, below is everything I could figure out that was a problem. We need to find replacements for the numbered items.

 

[Northman]

There's got to be some official erratta on this. You know the fellas at WotC have already made adjustments for their games.

 

[Ezieer]

...

 

[Emiricol]

Ezieer,

Thanks so much for participating. In fact, I'd be happy to send you the section on gods with attendant tables, and perhaps you could lead the project to revise that section? Then once the data is accurate we can get the final editing done right, without worrying.

But, if all you can do is help work out these domains, that is still a huge contribution

 

[Ezieer]

I'd suggest you use the names in parenthesis for clarity. Coolness vs. Confusion

Unresolved..

Beastmaster - Murrhygn

The following domains are found here:

The Complete Divine (for v3.5)
================================================

Celerity - Alyhndro
Community - Suerl
Creation - Kovar
Glory - Alyhndro
Madness - Lunakav
Weather - Talina​

Player's Guide to Faerun (for v3.5)
================================================

Artifice* (Craft) - Kovar
Cavern - Aethaddyn, Uluk
Charm - Bajaer, Belarna
Darkness* - Aethaddyn, Kirok
Elf - Targan Lithmoor
Fate - Felicitas, Prosimus
Halfling - Felicitas
Hatred - Parushan
Metal - Kovar
Moon* - Lunakav
Nobility - Aohalim, Os, Targan Lithmoor
Orc - Uluk
Renewal - Murryghn
Rune - Os
Saurian (Scalykind) - Naeron
Slime - Aethaddyn
Spider* - Shadoth
Storm - Eraekoth, Kirok, Typhus
Suffering - Caelon, Parushan
Time - Alyhndro
Tyranny - Beher
Undeath - Murryghn​

 

[Emiricol]

We wanted to make all our domains OGL compliant though

 

[Kognus]

Hello all,

Since Shadoth is my god, I will fix his domain spells. Do they need to be replaced completly, re-named or what. What do I need to do?

Thanks,

 

[Ezieer]

Hello all,

Since Shadoth is my god, I will fix his domain spells. Do they need to be replaced completly, re-named or what. What do I need to do?

Thanks,

He is fine in my opinion. The statement wanting things to be "OGL compliant" is previously moot. It wasn't before. All these other domains when this was 3.0 were 'taken' from other places before... not from the SRD.

To make these OGL, they would have be compiled from scratch. That would mean.

1) Completely different names.
2) Different Domain powers.
3) Somewhat different domain spell lists.

I'm not sure many people will be too happy with that. IMHO

 

[Emiricol]

I'm going to let out a really big sigh right now. Ok, here goes. They were *supposed* to be OGL before, but when I went to revise the guide to bring it from 3.0 to 3.5 I discovered that many domains weren't.

Saying they all need to be done from scratch is I think incorrect, since most of the domains were custom jobs.

Some of the remaining ones (see first post) need revision. That's all I'm asking.


Kognus - for Shaddoth the only problem I see is that the "Spider" domain includes FRSC-specific spells in slots 6, 7 and 9. Our Spider domain needs to be revised to not include FRSC-specific spells is all. It might need more work than merely replacing those spells, to keep the power progression right, but it might be just that simple depending on the spells selected.