Survivor Magic Swords- FROST BRAND CHILLS THE COMPETITION!

[Maxperson]

Dancing Sword 17
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 19
Frost Brand 22
Holy Avenger 16
Luck Blade 22
Nine Lives Stealer 15
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 15
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 11
Sword of Vengeance 16
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 18

Perhaps those you down voting "Sword + Something" fail to grasp what + means.

 

[Maxperson]

Vorpal Sword 22 -2 = 20. A lot of jibber jabber. (Besides, any weapon ought to be able to one shot kill most things.)

No no. It's not jibber jabber. It's Jabberwocky or perhaps snicker snack, but definitely not jibber jabber.

 

[lowkey13]

*Deleted by user*

 

[lowkey13]

*Deleted by user*

 

[rczarnec]

Dancing Sword 17
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 19
Frost Brand 22
Holy Avenger 15
Luck Blade 22
Nine Lives Stealer 13
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 15
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 11
Sword of Vengeance 16
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 19

 

[Dausuul]

Dancing Sword 17
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 19
Frost Brand 23: This is my ideal magic item. It's mechanically strong and also very flavorful. +1d6 cold damage is the core argument for wielding it; resistance to fire damage is an excellent perk; extinguishing fires and glowing in cold temperatures are pure flavor, but nifty.
Holy Avenger 15
Luck Blade 22
Nine Lives Stealer 13
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 15
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 9: When something is boring, it is actually worse to have it be mechanically powerful. There should not be a tradeoff between effectiveness and fun.
Sword of Vengeance 16
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 19

 

[OB1]

Dancing Sword 17
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 19
Frost Brand 23
Holy Avenger 15
Luck Blade 22
Nine Lives Stealer 13+1=14
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 15
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 9
Sword of Vengeance 16
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 19-2=17

 

[Gradine]

Dancing Sword 17
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 19
Frost Brand 23
Holy Avenger 16 - Can't let this drop off right away; something's gotta keep lowkey's ego in check
Luck Blade 22
Nine Lives Stealer 14
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 13 - Grog grog grog
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 9
Sword of Vengeance 16
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 17

 

[CleverNickName]

Dancing Sword 17-2=15
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 19
Frost Brand 23
Holy Avenger 16
Luck Blade 22
Nine Lives Stealer 14
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 13
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 9+1=10
Sword of Vengeance 16
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 17

I don't necessarily disagree with [MENTION=58197]Dausuul[/MENTION], but...well, anything will be boring if you just phone it in and read it off a list to your players. Just sayin'. "The Lost Mines of Phandelver" has a couple of Plus Something weapons that are rather interesting.

 

[mortwatcher]

Dancing Sword 15
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 19
Frost Brand 23
Holy Avenger 16
Luck Blade 23
Nine Lives Stealer 14
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 13
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 8
Sword of Vengeance 16
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 17