A few other notes, from someone who worked as a crafter at the Bristol faire (Chicago/Milwaukee) for 9 years.
rkwoodard said:
1) A good faire will have performers and street actors that make it fun for the guest, but yes, it is a blast to be in on the inside. And if the faire has a campground for the performers/merchants, then after hours is a total party. And from heresay, back in the day (late 70s and 80s) those after hour parties were the height of hedonism.
Agreed that the "insiders" have a different experience. I'm a little surprised that the faire in question had so many visible "cast only" areas, and that the cast spent so much time there. Many faires will have off-stage areas for the cast members to relax, and expect that, if the cast is in a public area, they'll be interacting with the public.
We used to joke around with a little ditty that we'd sing when the gates closed at 7pm, and a few stragglers wouldn't leave:
Ren Faire people
Eat human flesh
After 7 pm, oh yeah
When the gates closed on Saturday night, we'd change out of costume, fire up the barbecue grill, have dinner and beer, and sit around, drinking and singing, until about midnight, when the security staff would ask us to call it a night.
rkwoodard said:
3) Beer. Most faires do not have a good selection of beers/alchol.
Yeah, that's my experience, too. I think that most people who go to ren faires are
not interested in trying something funky or "period"; they want a lot of Bud Light. Our faire did broaden their selections, and brought in some imports and a microbrew or two, but generally speaking, it's a lot of mass-market American beer.
rkwoodard said:
4) Shopping is totally dependent on the faire. The TN faire has some good booths and some that are not ren at all.
Exactly. The wares at a faire are entirely dependent on what is popular with the visitors to that faire. At Bristol, there's quite a few visitors who like to come in costume, and so, there's always been quite a few shops that sell costume pieces. At the Minnesota faire, which I've visited a few times, very few visitors dress up, and the types of shops there are very different.
Generally speaking, it's important to keep in mind that "gamer geeks" like us are in the distinct minority of those who go to faires. The kinds of things that appeal to us are pretty niche, even for fairegoers.
Also, each faire has different policies about what they allow to be sold -- some try to stay true to period crafts, while others are far more liberal (my wife bought an electric lamp at the Minnesota faire; Bristol would have never allowed something like that to be sold).