Zweischneid
First Post
But what about when the PHB2, 3, etc. comes out? I see no reason not to allow at least what's in there, even if for some reason you wanted to draw a line at campaign books (though you'd be missing out on perfectly good drow, genasi, swordmage in FR, and artificer in Eb).
I would vote against using material from PHB 2, etc.., for the reasons outlined above. PHB, and thats it.
I know thats a choice that wont be popular (no Druids??? no Bards??) but I think it would suit the concept best.