Jack99
Adventurer
We can compare anecdotes all day long about our own demographic bubbles and if 4e is or isn't doing well therein, but without hard sales figures for various books we can't draw solid conclusions at this stage.
It's kinda funny (or sad, rather)
When Mona comes and says that Pathfinder is doing awesome and that Paizo hasn't stopped gaining more customers and selling since the announcement of the PFRPG, not a single soul questions his motives, nor his veracity. It's a fact.
Yet when Mearls, Rouse and Slavichek all post about how 4e is breaking all sorts of records, selling extremely well, all the nay-sayers keep questioning these statements, claiming there are no hard facts.
sigh