Urriak Uruk
Gaming is fun, and fun is for everyone
Hello! So I occasionally see folks here asking what their next 5E adventure they should run, but usually the answers given are mixed. Every player and DM has their own personal tastes after all, with some valuing things like colorful maps, or more of a sandbox, or dungeons crawls. So I thought, what is the closest method one could get to an unbiased poll of adventures... without actually doing a poll here (because no offense, this forum is a little skewed towards non-casual gamers).
So here is my attempt at ranking every 5E adventure, using two metrics; overall average score of reviews, with the proportion of "perfect" scores breaking ties (if two books have the same average review, but one has a higher proportion of 5-stars, it moves ahead). Also, this is using Amazon.com, so is primarily US purchases, the biggest market (but not all reviewers). This is also just ranking true adventures, not including boxes or books that include short adventures.
Let me know if you think this ranking is actually fairly accurate... or if there is some quality that this metric completely misses.
Curse of Strahd: 4.9 score, 91%. 4,625 reviews.
Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden: 4.8 score, 88%. 5,240 reviews.
Waterdeep: Dragon Heist: 4.8 score, 88%. 3,465 reviews.
Baldur's Gate: Descent into Avernus: 4.8 score, 88%. 3,312 reviews.
Tomb of Annihilation: 4.8 score, 88%. 2,224 reviews.
Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage. 4.8 score, 87%. 2,418 reviews.
Ghosts of Saltmarsh: 4.8 score, 86%. 3,052 reviews.
Tales from the Yawning Portal: 4.8 score, 86%. 2,567 reviews.
Out of the Abyss: 4.8 score, 86%. 1,689 reviews.
Storm King's Thunder: 4.8 score, 86%. 1,653 reviews.
Rise of Tiamat: 4.8 score, 85%. 1,943 reviews.
Candlekeep Mysteries: 4.8 score, 83%. 2,133 reviews.
Hoard of the Dragon Queen: 4.7 score, 83%. 2,530 reviews.
Princes of the Apocalypse: 4.7 score, 81%. 1,335 reviews.
So here is my attempt at ranking every 5E adventure, using two metrics; overall average score of reviews, with the proportion of "perfect" scores breaking ties (if two books have the same average review, but one has a higher proportion of 5-stars, it moves ahead). Also, this is using Amazon.com, so is primarily US purchases, the biggest market (but not all reviewers). This is also just ranking true adventures, not including boxes or books that include short adventures.
Let me know if you think this ranking is actually fairly accurate... or if there is some quality that this metric completely misses.
Curse of Strahd: 4.9 score, 91%. 4,625 reviews.
Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden: 4.8 score, 88%. 5,240 reviews.
Waterdeep: Dragon Heist: 4.8 score, 88%. 3,465 reviews.
Baldur's Gate: Descent into Avernus: 4.8 score, 88%. 3,312 reviews.
Tomb of Annihilation: 4.8 score, 88%. 2,224 reviews.
Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage. 4.8 score, 87%. 2,418 reviews.
Ghosts of Saltmarsh: 4.8 score, 86%. 3,052 reviews.
Tales from the Yawning Portal: 4.8 score, 86%. 2,567 reviews.
Out of the Abyss: 4.8 score, 86%. 1,689 reviews.
Storm King's Thunder: 4.8 score, 86%. 1,653 reviews.
Rise of Tiamat: 4.8 score, 85%. 1,943 reviews.
Candlekeep Mysteries: 4.8 score, 83%. 2,133 reviews.
Hoard of the Dragon Queen: 4.7 score, 83%. 2,530 reviews.
Princes of the Apocalypse: 4.7 score, 81%. 1,335 reviews.