Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Manbearcat" data-source="post: 6650510" data-attributes="member: 6696971">Hmmmm...1e:&nbsp; * Gold for xp.* Melee needs to be more sticky by itself.* Brutal SoD traps and magic.* Non-proficient saves need to scale pretty near to the proficient ones (especially for fighters).* Warrior classes need to be able to cut through piles of mooks rather than being vulnerable to them.* All monsters need to be a hell of a lot more dangerous.* Lessen the impact of HD on the game.* Roll initiative each round/phases.* Thieves and Monks need to be nerfed.&nbsp; Then again.&nbsp; Then again.&nbsp; Maybe one more time for good measure.2eEverything in 1e except Gold for xp and no Monks.&nbsp; Also...* Demons and Devils need to be named Bobs and Larries (or something equivalent).* 50 more elven subraces.* Use the speed factor stuff.* Lots of DMPCs.* The PCs need to be tourists as they take in the DM's rendering of their favorite setting.* Lots of DM force and random stuff to keep the whole thing together.3.x* Melee needs to be filled with quick-set cement.* Get rid of Concentration and give the Wizard more spells and higher DCs.* Probably split up Backgrounds to individual &quot;Proficiency Points&quot; that players can spend as Skill Points.* Going to have to figure out a magic item economy.* Trade Hit Dice for Wands of Cure Light Wounds.4e...errr yeah...this big tent ain't big enough for all of us.&nbsp; Go play your heretical not-D&amp;D elsewhere.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Manbearcat, post: 6650510, member: 6696971"] Hmmmm... 1e: * Gold for xp. * Melee needs to be more sticky by itself. * Brutal SoD traps and magic. * Non-proficient saves need to scale pretty near to the proficient ones (especially for fighters). * Warrior classes need to be able to cut through piles of mooks rather than being vulnerable to them. * All monsters need to be a hell of a lot more dangerous. * Lessen the impact of HD on the game. * Roll initiative each round/phases. * Thieves and Monks need to be nerfed. Then again. Then again. Maybe one more time for good measure. 2e Everything in 1e except Gold for xp and no Monks. Also... * Demons and Devils need to be named Bobs and Larries (or something equivalent). * 50 more elven subraces. * Use the speed factor stuff. * Lots of DMPCs. * The PCs need to be tourists as they take in the DM's rendering of their favorite setting. * Lots of DM force and random stuff to keep the whole thing together. 3.x * Melee needs to be filled with quick-set cement. * Get rid of Concentration and give the Wizard more spells and higher DCs. * Probably split up Backgrounds to individual "Proficiency Points" that players can spend as Skill Points. * Going to have to figure out a magic item economy. * Trade Hit Dice for Wands of Cure Light Wounds. 4e ...errr yeah...this big tent ain't big enough for all of us. Go play your heretical not-D&D elsewhere. [/QUOTE]

Verification