2006 WotC D&D Product Survivor - Round 12

[Glyfair]

The last of the Eberron books, Dragonmarked was voted off last round. Again, the top vote getter will be removed after the next round.

 

[Crothian]

Dragonmarked was a really good book, too.

 

[Glyfair]

Dragonmarked was a really good book, too.

I agree, although I liked Secrets of Xen'drik much better.

The only book I consider didn't belong in the top 10 that made it (either based on first or second hand information) was Twilight Tomb.

This round I voted for the first Fiendish Codex. The very idea of coming up with a canon Abyss is so contradictory, IMO.

 

[Kunimatyu]

Interestingly, based on what I'm seeing here, the mega-adventures seem to have been well-recieved -- they're right up there with the top player option and monster-type books, which means that they're doing better than the environment, FR, and Eberron lines, and better than books like DMG2 and MM4.

I'll probably vote for Complete Mage or Slaughtergarde this year. CM was good but suffers from the 'hey, -another- Complete Magicuser Book' syndrome, and Slaughtergarde I really just don't know as well as the others, and I really like all the others.

 

[delericho]

Getting close to the point where I can vote again

Added bonus - four of my top five from the year are still in the running. Two others I passed on, and the final book I own, but haven't read yet.

Interestingly, based on what I'm seeing here, the mega-adventures seem to have been well-recieved

They're really good adventures. Well, "Red Hand" and "Slaughtergarde" are - I don't know about Ravenloft so can't comment. Of the two, "Red Hand" is definately the stronger IMO.

 

[Shade]

This round I voted for the first Fiendish Codex. The very idea of coming up with a canon Abyss is so contradictory, IMO.

You're making me cry. We are as far apart on this issue as LG and CE are on the alignment axis.