Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Rasyr" data-source="post: 3329039" data-attributes="member: 2855">It can matter... It depends on the image that the ENnies wants to project. Image does not always follow reason...I do not dislike any of the judges, nor do I dislike the ENnies. I think that there are some POTENTIAL problem areas and I would like to see them addressed publicly since these are supposed to be a fan-based awards, the fans SHOULD have the chance to give their input.My questions for the judges (and thanks to P-kitty for answer the one about the Mods) are meant to specifically to elicit their opinions and thoughts on things that I think are important regarding the ENnies, as opposed to some of the silly questions asked. I assure you that I take the ENnies very seriously and have a great amount of respect for them. I just happen to think that they can be even better. And since I am not a stake-holder this year, I feel that I can fully and freely express my opinions in order to ask those in charge to make things better overall and fairer to all.More questions for judges....Do you think that a codified set of rules cannot include provisions for making changes and/or updating them as conditions and the market change?Do you think it is wrong to have a basic set of rules be codified and put forth to let participant know exactly what points they will be judged on? Do make sure that each judge is judging the entrants on the same points?(Note: granted each judge would put their own significance to each point, but at least they would all be covering the same points?)Do you think that products entered in the main categories should be allowed to be included in other main categories by the judges?Do you think that Categories should have at least a minimal description/standard to determine whether or not a product should be included in that category (i.e. that a book is required to be at least 50% about the setting to be considered for Best Setting)?</blockquote>

Verification